Monday, July 13, 2009

The Earliest Eumetazoan Progression

ResearchBlogging.org
I have commented several times on the early evolution of the animals, especially in regard to their ability to handle information.  Here I want to look at the progression from a plausible common ancestor of the latest-branching clade of sponges and the Eumetazoans to the point of a plausible last common ancestor of the Ctenophores, the Cnidarians, and the Bilaterians. 

Symmetry and Development

Since, in my view, all (or most) of the animals in the sequence we're looking at had biradial symmetry, I'll start with a discussion of that.  (Especially since Wiki has only a stub on the subject). 

First, as I've mentioned before, symmetry in all animals that move in response to external directional cues must be superficial.  Even if the animal is only a sphere with sensory cells and ciliated swimming cells distributed evenly over its surface, the communications needed to coordinate its swimming with the direction of threats and food will require each cell to know its location relative to the whole.  There can be no confusion between left and right, front and back, top and bottom.  This requires a coordinate system of some sort, even if the physical morphology doesn't show it.  For a spherical surface, there are two obvious options:  radial (or angular) and multipolar. 

The radial system is like the system of latitude and longitude:  it starts with a pair of poles on opposite sides of the sphere, which we will call "oral and "aboral", named after the blastopore or (single) gut opening in these early animals.  (Sponge larvae also demonstrate this polarity in their distribution of cell types, although they lack a blastopore.)  A line between the poles (along the surface -- one through the center of the sphere is the axis) is then defined as the "zero longitude" line, after which any spot on the spherical surface may be uniquely located by its angular location relative to the poles (latitude), and its angular location relative to the "zero longitude" line.  Of course, it will still have to know clockwise from counter-clockwise:  30° longitude is very different from -30°. 

The multipolar system also starts out with a polar axis, but then goes on to define another (which might roughly correspond to 0° and 180° longitude) and then yet another (which might correspond to 90° and 270°).  any location on the spherical surface is uniquely defined by three numbers:  how far it is between each of the three pairs of poles. 

Controlling the Development of Symmetry

Now, location in animals is almost always defined in terms of the diffusion of signaling molecules, a system well supported by a good epithelium.  The tight junctions among all the superficial cells prevents these molecules from diffusing out into the surrounding medium, and the basal layer(s) can be specialized to allow much faster diffusion along than across it.  The first set of poles, then, can define "latitude" with a cluster of cells at one end releasing a diffusible signal:  latitude is known by the concentration of the signal.  ...

A more robust mechanism would have cells at the other end also releasing a signaling chemical, a different one.  Now a cell on the surface could get its latitude by sampling the relative concentrations of two chemical signals.  This is a typical system in some developing embryos, although the oral signal usually comes from a ring of cells surrounding the blastopore. 

If we try to use such a mechanism in the radial coordinate system, the "zero longitude" line would have to emit its signal in only one direction (or two signals, each in one direction), or else it would be impossible to distinguish clockwise from counter-clockwise.  (Alternatively, a separate signal could be released at a point some angle away from the "zero longitude" line, but this is becoming a hybrid with the multipolar system.) 

The multipolar system has this problem solved, at the cost of three signals (or pairs of signal chemicals).  this is, in effect, what bilaterians all use, and IMO it's likely that research will eventually discover that the Ctenophores and Cnidarians do as well. 

With all this in hand, let's look at symmetry.  Since the Cnidarian medusa forms have a well-defined radial symmetry around their oral/aboral axis, we'll start with that.  If we imagine a glove with poles, latitude, longitude, and an equator, let's break the equator into four equal sections, broken at 0°, 90°, 180°, and 270°.  We'll define a primary mirror image at each break line, so each section looks identical to its reflection in each mirror.  We'll also define a second set of mirrors intermediate to the the first, at 45°-225° and 135°-315°.  Each section, then, is identical to every other, and to its reflection across the primary mirror line.  Each section's halves are also identical but inverted across the secondary mirror line running down its middle.  This is radial symmetry with an index of four.  A simple square has this sort of symmetry.  It can be divided into four identical sections, reflected in the two mirror axes, with each section having identical but inverted "left" and "right" halves.  Note that if you divide a square into eight sections, four of them will be inverted relative to the others.  Note also that it doesn't matter which set of axes you define as primary, and which secondary:  a square can be divided into four sides (sharing corners) or four corners (each with two half-sides). 

Now, many Cnidarians have a higher index than four, such as eight, or sixteen.  It's easy to see how these body plans can be achieved developmentally.  for instance, if we start with an index of four, at each point where one of the primary planes of symmetry (reflection) intersects the equator (or some other circle of equal "latitude"), there's a small patch of cells emitting a chemical signal.  For robustness, there should be another patch at each point where a secondary plane intersects, emitting another chemical.  By sampling this signal, any cell can know where it is within the section it occupies.  Note that for coordinated control, each arm, at least, will have to know its location relative to the entire organism's coordinate system. 

How does a developing organism double its index?  At a specific point in development, a signal is released telling the cells at the secondary points to begin emitting the primary signal (instead of the secondary), and a group of cells halfway between each set (who already knew their position from the earlier signals) begin emitting the secondary signal.  Now the index is eight.  this process can be repeated as many times as needed, and it's a simple mutation to increase (or decrease) the number of repeats. 

I've described how the multipolar system could produce four poles equally distributed around the equator, if a patch of cells at each of these poles started emitting the primary signal, and cells that found themselves at the midpoints began emitting the secondary signal, you've got radial symmetry with an index of four.  But more interesting is how those four poles came to be. 

Let's start with a simple sphere with no coordinate system except a single patch of cells (somewhere, anywhere on the surface).  If these cells begin emitting a signal (different from the signals used in radial symmetry), it will diffuse around the sphere while breaking down and diffusing away (at right angles to the surface, which is presumably an epithelium capable of controlling the diffusion rates in different directions).  Thus the concentration will reduce from a maximum at the emitting pole to a minimum at its antipode.  Cells are capable of detecting a concentration gradient, the fact that there is none is enough to let cells at the antipode know that they should begin emitting the opposite signal. 

More problematical is the next pole.  Some mechanism is needed to select this pole (somewhere on the equator), various species use various methods, some of which are essentially random.  Once this pole is selected, cells here may begin emitting a new signal (still probably different from those used in radial symmetry), which diffuses around the equator and allows its antipode to form in the same way as the first.  The third pole also requires some external mechanism to distinguish between left and right, although cells equidistant between the second poles will know it.  In many species this selection is random, although mammals[20] and everybody's favorite flatworm Caenorhabditis elegans[21] have fairly reliable mechanisms for determining their left side. 

When it comes to radial symmetry, we've seen how four-fold symmetry can come about, but what if only two poles begin emitting the primary signal, while those at right angles to their axis begin emitting the secondary signal?  This is radial symmetry with an index of two:  biradial symmetry.  Ctenophores have a fundamental biradial symmetry, as do most Cnidarian polyps. 

(Ctenophores have imposed an eightfold symmetry on their oral end and the major expansions of their gut, but the aboral end is biradial.  (The location of the "anal pores" breaks this symmetry, creating a rotational symmetry with an index of 2, but this is a minor feature, and I'm going to class it with the giant left claws of some crabs:  a minor break asymmetry built on the basic symmetry.) Cnidarian Medusae also have a basal biradial symmetry underlying their 4-, 8-, or 16-fold symmetry.  And remember that all symmetry is ultimately superficial:  there is always an underlying coordinate system that uniquely defines each point.) 

Symmetry and Controlling the Body

When it comes to controlling the body, symmetry has an advantage in that the same behavioral program can be used for each unit of symmetry.  This applies both to the behavior of cells in the developing organism, and the behavior of units (limbs, tentacles) in the active animal.  Even when differences arise, they can be overlaid on the repeated pattern:  there will usually be many more similarities than differences, which means much less information is needed to define the entirety when symmetry is used.  It also means that mutation to the underlying pattern can change all the units at once, which has advantages and disadvantages when it comes to overlaid differences.  (But selection can take advantage of mutations that play to the advantages, while weeding out those that run into disadvantages.) 

This makes much more difference to an animal that uses muscles to make coordinated changes to its body shape than to blobs swimming around with cilia, so for the origins of Eumetazoan symmetry we need to look to the ultimate origins of muscles. 

Symmetry in the Earliest Animals

I've suggested that the common ancestor of Eumetazoans and the latest-branching clade of sponges, the homoscleromorpha, was a small globular animal like a swimming sponge:  containing internal water canals, with the porocytes spread across the front, cilia for swimming in a broad belt around the middle, and a fairly sophisticated system for controlling its activity.  What I didn't make explicit was that the osculum, the exit for water flowing through the body, would have been in the rear, so that the flows of water from swimming and feeding could complement one another, and so that oxygen-depleted water from either would not become input tot eh other.  Being roughly spheroidal, this creature's swimming actions would have been identical in any direction around its "oral/aboral" axis. 

It might seem, in these early days, that there wasn't much need for swimming, given the general lack of predators, but we need to consider the early environment:  most models of the pre-Cambrian biosphere suggest that the deeper oceans were anoxic, with only a shallow layer of oxygenated water overlying it.  With much of the productivity confined to the coastal areas, where tides and wave actions continually stirred things up, there would have been vast opportunities for collecting food in regions with substantial risk of being stranded by wave action.  this means that some ability to predict wave action and position itself so as to be washed back out in a breaking wave rather than getting stranded on a sandy beach would have given an animal a selective advantage, even for an animal that could only swim with cilia.  More predictive ability would have conferred more benefit, so we have a situation where the evolution of intelligence has a nice steep "fitness slope" to climb, even without changes to the body structure. 

In this regard, I want to discuss a particularly important paper,[14] which is unfortunately behind a paywall:  Sponge Genes Provide New Insight into the Evolutionary Origin of the Neurogenic Circuit (by Gemma S. Richards, Elena Simionato, Muriel Perron, Maja Adamska, Michel Vervoort, and Bernard M. Degnan).  What these researchers did was identify a gene in an early-branching sponge, Amphimedon queenslandica which is a demosponge, that appears to be descended from an ancestor of many types of genes involved in controlling the development of nerve cells in the bilaterians, and presumably also the other eumetazoans.  Not only that, but they injected mRNA for the protein coded by this gene into frog and fruit fly embryos, and determined that it performed many of the neurogenic functions of its purported relative genes native to these animals.

Now in Amphimedon queenslandica this gene, called AmqbHLH1 is expressed along with a similar relative of the notch receptor genes of eumetazoans and a notch ligand, AmqDelta1, in the outer layer of cells of the early embryo.  As it develops, the embryo separates into three layers, the inner cell, subepithelial, and epithelial. 
Prior to the formation of the subepithelial layer (“spot stage”), all three of the conserved neurogenic genes are expressed in the outer layer (Figures 1A–1D), with AmqNotch expressed broadly and AmqDelta1 and AmqbHLH1 restricted to subpopulations of cells. A few hours later at the “early ring stage” (Figures 1E–1H), all three genes are coexpressed in cells of the subepithelial layer.  In “late ring embryos” (Figures 1I–1L), AmqbHLH1 and AmqNotch remain expressed in the subepithelial layer, but AmqDelta1 is now highly expressed in globular cells that are located beyond the subepithelial layer, within the outer layer.  We propose that the expression of AmqDelta1 in the globular cell population is continuous and that it tracks a specific migratory event from its initiation, when cells leave the subepithelial layer, until its conclusion, when the cells reach their final position scattered around the outer margin of the mature larva (Figures 1M–1P).[14]
These Globular Cells appear to function as sensory cells, helping the sponge "larva" find a spot to settle and metamorphose into a small version of the adult form.

Now, I've previously suggested that when looking at larvae, we shouldn't consider them to be representative of the immediate ancestor of the adult form, but rather a specialized developmental stage, simplified in many respects for the purpose of extremely rapid growth, that may in some respects recall ancestral forms, often very distant ancestors.  I've also pointed out that in the classic definition of "larva", this form is specialized for growth, and we shouldn't assume that a form that does little but swim around and settle is similar to classic larvae.  But it's reasonable that the "larvae" of sponges are descended from a more classic version of larvae, in which case their ancestors spent some time swimming around finding and eating large amounts of food before settling and metamorphosing.

So it's plausible that these larvae used an ancestral method of controlling their swimming, harking back to a "swimming sponge" ancestor that possessed a sophisticated system of controlling its movements, combining sensation and intelligence.  The fact that remnants, quite likely far simpler than what the ancestor had, may be found in ancestral larvae makes it very plausible that the ancestor itself had something much better.  It may not have been strictly divided into nerve cells and sensory cells as is often the case in more developed eumetazoans, but that didn't mean it wasn't capable of considerable intelligence.

And these weren't just the common ancestors of the latest branch prior to the Eumetazoans:  Amphimedon queenslandica is a demosponge, a group that branched prior to the homoscleromorphs, showing that intelligence was already evolving prior to the latest branching.

What, precisely, were the active resources available to this evolving intelligence?  We know that some sponges can propagate an electro-chemical (actually electro-osmoidal) wave along their epithelia, stimulating closure of the porocytes, the latter function being present in all sponge lineages.  We also know of sponges that can expel a large proportion of the water in their canal system, although the process takes too long to be useful in emergency swimming.  (But then, sponges don't swim, so it's plausible that this function had degenerated from a faster one in swimming ancestors.) 

Speculative Reconstructions

But what if our early "swimming sponges" had a greatly enlarged osculum, such that they resembled a hollow sphere with an opening in the back and their systems of water canals and their bodies in a layer surrounding the hollow full of water?  In this case, a contraction around the equator, coupled with a relaxation at a right angle, along the "oral/aboral" lines, could have produced a large reduction in the volume of the enclose space, without reducing the surface area.  Indeed, a reduction in surface area would have been no problem, as long as a thickening of the body layer could compensate to keep the overall body volume unchanged, since the major speed impediment is squeezing the water out of all those tiny channels. 

We know, from observations of Cnidarians, that it's possible for epithelial cells to produce substantial contractions, and other changes in shape.  What makes muscles so powerful is their organization of myosin, actin, and other proteins into specialized linear structures that can shorten quickly in response to action potentials.[4] [5] [6] All Eukaryote cells possess forms of myosin and actin, which they use for a variety of movements within the cell, including changing its shape and moving organelles around.  The organization of many overlapping fibers of actin and myosin into something like muscles probably constituted a smooth "fitness slope" which could be easily climbed through progressive small mutations to the organization and structure of myosins and actins in the cell.

We can start with the epithelial cells creating bundles of these overlapping fibers connecting membranes on opposing sides of the cell, with some sort of trans-membrane structures providing mechanical linkage across the pair of cell walls.  If the cells were connected by gap junctions that could propagate the electrical waves of action potentials from cell to cell, the entire skin could have contracted quickly to expel water in the oversized osculum for escape swimming.  The development from this point to the simple myotubes of Ctenophores is probably a progression of simple refinements.

A key obstacle to this sort of swimming is that there are limits to the internal flexibility of the water-canal filled sponge, which in turn produce limits to how much water could be expelled.  Although it's hard to be sure, I suspect that no more than 30% to 50% of the total volume could be made up of expellable water.  To enlarge the body cavity further, allowing for greater emergency swimming, the creature would have to give up its circular symmetry around the "oral/aboral" axis, and collapse in some way that produced a lesser symmetry.

An obvious candidate is biradial symmetry.  A spheroid can flatten into a shape roughly like a pumpkin seed, reducing its volume to a tiny fraction of the original.  But to do this, the internal skeleton (presumably much like that of small modern sponges without spicules), would have to become specialized in a biradial pattern.  The part that becomes the flat part of the "pumpkin seed" would have to be resistant to further bending, while being able to flatten out from its spherical curvature.  And the part that becomes the edge would have to be much more conducive to bending, becoming something of a hinge.

Similar biradial specializations would be necessary for the contractile cells.  Indeed, while "shrinking" a sphere could be accomplished by contracting the outer skin, flattening it would require tension from more internal cells.  If such a system evolved gradually, the end result would be lines of cells penetrating the internal structure (between the water canals) which could contract, pulling on one another, to pull the appropriate parts of the outer skin into the "pumpkin seed" configuration.  These structures would be different in different areas around the equator, in a biradial configuration. 

Note that this simple system is only possible with an index of two.  Radial systems with higher indices would require not only a convex bend in the outer skin, but concave bends.  The structure of tensile elements (primitive myotubes) would also be extremely complex.  It is highly unlikely then that a higher index of symmetry would have arisen under these circumstances.

What we have, then, is a small swimming sponge in the form of a hollow sphere, with a fairly sophisticated "brain", capable of maneuvering through the wave-stirred coastal waters where large amounts of edible detritus was available and the constant stirring of the water provided a good supply of oxygen from the air.  It probably didn't have nerve cells (in the sense of having axons carrying action potentials), rather the cells that performed calculations and communications may have looked much more like the modern mammalian astrocytes:  cells with multiple processes reaching out to all (or many of) the cells in its vicinity, having an ability to perform localized calculations and carry signals by means of "calcium waves" that could transfer from one cell to another over the electrical connections made by gap junctions.  They may well have also performed sensory functions, lacking the division into specialized cell types found in Eumetazoans.

Building the First Eumetazoans

The transition from this to the Eumetazoans almost certainly required the key transition from internal water canals and chambers lined with choanocytes to a system of mucociliary feeding similar to that seen in a huge variety of Eumetazoan larvae and many adults.  In this system, mucus is secreted from parts of the skin that are supplied with large numbers of cilia of two types:  one type stays within the mucus and keeps it moving, eventually collecting into channels which feed it into the mouth.  The other type sticks up out of the mucus, and sweeps water along the mucus covered skin, moving in a way that tends to force suspended particles (and life-forms) down into the mucus where they stick and are drawn along with it into the mouth where they are digested.

Mucus is a rather complex secretion, present in sponges as well as most Eumetazoans.  It performs important protective functions by trapping would-be invaders where they can be isolated from the underlying skin.  It is made up primarily of glycoproteins and complex sugars, well supplied with other materials secreted by the underlying cells.  The composition can easily vary by species, and many of the various mucins can co-evolve with digestive enzymes, allowing a species to secrete mucus it can easily digest but that most of the living creatures trapped in it can't break down.

The easiest path by which a swimming sponge might evolve into a mucociliary feeder is to begin with using mucus as a defensive mechanism.  Many sponges have cilia, so it's an easy adaptation to using them to move secreted mucus along the surface to somewhere that trapped would-be invaders wouldn't be a threat.  Most sponges have amoeboid cells that can feed using phagocytosis, which actually isn't that different from the process used by choanocytes when one of the microvilli around their flagellum traps a food particle.  (Indeed, there are sponges that have multinucleated aboeboids that feed on small crabs and other crustaceans with a similar process.) It's an easy adaptation for these cells to develop the ability to secrete proteins (or keep them on the outer surface of their cell membranes) that would cause the mucus to become thinner right around them, allowing them to "swim" through it and chase down, trap, and eat whatever they find caught in it.  They would also have the ability to collect large amounts of this mucus, digest it back into its basic components, and return packages of these materials into the internal matrix of the animal, where they could be transported back to the cells that secrete mucus for reuse.

The next adaptation would be to modify part of the inner surface of the osculum as a "trap" for this mucus, with the cells lining it being specialized to be resistant to attack from whatever invaders are caught in the mucus.  Alternatively, this trap might be lined with a syncytium of cells capable of surrounding and absorbing such invaders.  A further adaptation would be for the "trap" to develop the ability to close itself away from the outside intermittently, then some of the cells lining it could secrete acids or other chemicals that would alter the environment to one much more hostile to invaders adapted to the open ocean (or whatever).  This would also allow the secretion of digestive enzymes, both to break down the mucus for reuse of its components (without the effort of absorption by the amoeboid cells, and to break down the tissues of the various trapped invaders.  At this point we have a rudimentary gastric system, although it has originated as part of a protective mechanism rather than the primary method of feeding.

However, given a creature that already uses cilia to move water around for swimming, and has now developed their use to move mucus over the skin, it's another easy adaptation to modify some of the ciliary action to sweep food particles down onto the film of mucus, enhancing the ability to trap food.  At this point, it's reasonable to assume that some lineages would specialize in this process, abandoning the use of choanocytes and collared flagella.  The developmental mechanisms they had used to control the creation of water canals and choanocyte chambers would then be free to elaborate the shape of their ectoderm, providing specialized improvements for increased trapping of food with their now fully-developed muco-ciliary feeding system.

Here, then, is our fully emerged Eumetazoan.  It has biradial symmetry, uses cilia to swim, posses a blastopore, into which mucus full of suspended food is periodically swept, after which it closes so acids and digestive enzymes can be secreted into it and digestion can take place.  The lining of the digestive tract is probably a syncytium, as it is in the most basally-branching bilaterians, which may well preserve this feature from the earliest Eumetazoans.  (As I recently pointed out, both the Cnidarians and the Ctenophores are probably highly specialized, and cannot be expected to represent the early common ancestors.)

Eumetazaon Developments

Where does it go from here?  When we look at the ctenophores, we see a creature with a rudimentary sensory organ at the aboral end, two tentacles near it, and a system of (typically) eight lines of cilia running up from the oral opening towards the equator.  The Cnidarian medusa, which I've argued is the ancestral adult form of this group, has four-, eight-, or sixteen-fold radial symmetry, which as shown above could easily develop from a biradial ancestral condition (something regressed to in most of the (IMO) larval form represented by the polyp).  It's been shown by gene expression studies that the tentacles of polyps are not homologous to those of the Ctenophores, but I have an alternative suggestion.

I would propose a common ancestor with biradial symmetry, two tentacles at the aboral end used for swimming and other manipulative processes, and a set of tentacles around the mouth used primarily for mucociliary feeding.  The swimming would be for escaping wave action and possibly predators, and the location near the aboral sensory system and brain would allow faster communication.  The tentacles near the mouth would be well provided with cilia, along with mucus grooves, and normal "cruising" would be done using these.  Nerve cells would have been present (as they are in all descendant lineages), and muscle cells would have also been present, primarily in the aboral tentacles.

The progression from this ancestor to the Ctenophores is easily envisioned:  as it converts from filter feeding to pursuing and eating larger prey, the cilia surrounding its mouth become specialized for only swimming, "cruising", and they fold up around the body, producing lines of cilia spreading up from the oral end, and allowing a shorter path for messages from the brain controlling them.  The aboral tentacles, in turn, become specialized for capturing prey.  An intermediate form might have been one that supplemented its original mucociliary feeding with another type of filter feeding:  sweeping its tentacles through the water and trapping and eating whatever they encountered.  This would provide an easy evolutionary path for the development of the colloblasts.  They might well have begun as objects on the feeding tentacles surrounding the mouth, allowing them to trap any food particles they encounter, while the primary feeding method remained mucociliary.  Once they spread to the aboral tentacles, those tentacles could have begun using a sweeping process to capture objects that the oral tentacles couldn't, taking advantage of their muscles and faster responses.

Similarly, the progression towards the Cnidarians is equally easy to see.  Beginning with a similar animal, the aboral tentacles, already adapted for swimming, become duplicated, creating four, and widen towards the bell shape found in the modern medusa.  This would have started with a swimming action in which both tentacles pushed back at the same time, probably used by the original common ancestor.  Duplicating the tentacles, and widening them, would have been easy mutations, not having to occur in any specific order.  Once both had occurred, fusing them into a bell is another easy mutation.  After that, the development of tentacles hanging off the edge of the bell is also an easy mutation.  If the common ancestor had already had colloblasts, or something ancestral to them, these cells could later have become specialized for capturing active creatures with high-flow bloodstreams and complex nervous systems.  (I've discussed this progression already, in Coelenterates, Cnidarians, and Larvae.)

Getting back to the common ancestor, how did it come about?  Let's go back and start with the small spheroidal creature, with an outer covering of mucus-secreting skin and cilia to sweep this mucus back into the osculum, where it enters a primitive digestive system.  We've seen that the "swimming sponge" would have already had biradial symmetry and a sophisticated "brain" it could use for steering itself through the chaotic waters of food-filled beach areas.  Being hollow, with most of the volume enclosed by its body in the expanded form consisting of water it could expel for swimming, when it needed to escape some wave-created threat it could move quite far and fast for a very short distance.

What if, re-using the same developmental mechanisms it used to control the growth of the water-canal system, it developed a pair of tentacles sprouting from the "flat" sides (the sides that become flat when it expels water)?  These tentacles would ideally be as close as possible to the "brain" at the aboral end, and the myotubes along their length could have one end inserted into the "ganglion" that constituted the "brain", thus allowing this creature to steer itself during its escape swimming.  This mechanism might well have been present before the development of mucociliary feeding; it might even have been present in the common ancestor of the homosclerimorphs and the eumetazoans (and lost by the former as they evolved towards sessile feeding).

Given the ability to create tentacles for one purpose, it's yet another easy mutation for them to appear for another, in this case at the oral end.  If they were covered with mucociliary apparati, they would have enhanced the capture of food particles that didn't make it into the pores, because they were too far away from the line of swimming.  (Particles that were too large would have become trapped in the mucus covering the body; indeed that might well have been the primary reason for adopting mucociliary feeding as a strategy in place of simply recovering and reusing defensive resources and energy.)

An alternative model would be that the mucus flow along the body became concentrated in a pair of channels where they could flow into the osculum, around the rear edge.  This way, the mucus flow would be somewhat isolated from the flow of water, both normal and during escape swimming.  These channels could then have become supplemented by tentacles, again allowing the capture of food particles too far away from the swim line.

Once there were two tentacles, it was yet another easy mutation for them to multiply to four, eight, and even farther (as discussed above).  The more tentacles, the greater fraction of food that missed the body could be captured.

A creature with two major feeding strategies occupies an unstable position evolutionarily.  While such a life-style may be successful, even wildly successful, there is always the option for one or more descendant lineages to specialize in one and abandon the other.  Since the original strategy was a sponge like process, the progression would have been towards total dedication to mucociliary feeding, using the oral tentacles.  The cilia around the main body would have been abandoned (at least for normal swimming), since those on the tentacles would have been sufficient to capture anything in the water stream.  The hollow filled with water would also probably have eventually been abandoned, being replaced with the more efficient swimming using the aboral tentacles.  And there you have it, the common ancestor of the Cnidarians and the Ctenophores proposed above.

Now, most molecular investigations of the early ancestry of modern Eumetazoan lineages tell us that the Ctenophores branched first, with the other branch leading to the common ancestor of the Cnidarians (Coelenterates) and the Bilaterians.  The common ancestor of all three proposed above, then, would have been followed by the common ancestor of the Cnidarians and Bilaterians.  In my view, it probably looked very much like the earlier ancestor, but with a more developed nervous system.

Nerve Cells

The key to the invention of the nerve cell is the need to carry rapid messages over long distances, where muscle fibers can't do the job (because if they can there's no need for nerves, as shown above for the muscles in the early aboral tentacles, as well as some acoels, a group generally thought to be basally branching bilaterians, and thus likely representative of the early state).

We find nerve cells controlling the action of cilia in the Ctenophores, and this actually provides the most plausible explanation for their invention:  the long tentacles extending from around the mouth need their cilia controlled, especially during escape swimming.  We can see how cells originally more like astrocytes became specialized to carry a rapid action potential along their length so that they could deliver an almost simultaneous message to these ciliated cells.  Once this feature had been developed, such cells were also used for controlling muscles, allowing them to connect any two points on the epithelia (either ectodermal or endodermal) without the extra effort of extending processes to the "brain".

Note that there's probably no real need for nerve cells to control the action of the ciliated bands in Ctenophores:  the calcium waves found in astrocytes would probably be sufficient, given the overall slowness of this type of swimming.  However, if they evolved from an ancestor that used nerve cells to control the action of cilia at the end of long tentacles extending from around the mouth, this feature wouldn't have been given up, it would have simply been adapted for the need.

Thus, in this model, the common ancestor of all the modern Eumetazoans had already invented nerve cells, although their most essential use was for controlling ciliary activity.  At some time after the Ctenophore lineage(s) branched off, one group continued the development of its nervous system for more active control of its movement, perhaps extending myotubes into the oral tentacles, and developing a suite of sophisticated movement with the aboral tentacles for complex swimming movements.  Little real development of the physical form would have been necessary, in fact little development of the nervous system is really necessary:  the common ancestor of the Cnidarians and Eumetazoans might well have pretty much resembled the earlier common ancestor, the Cnidarian and Bilaterian lineages may just have branched later than the Ctenophores.

What about the progression to the Bilaterians?  Well, among the things that must have happened is a shuffling of developmental cues, as is shown, for instance, by the fact that the blastopore in developing bilaterians forms at the opposite end of the the egg from that of the others, based on the position of the polar body.  There are many other differences in how the bilaterians use the developmental genes they inherited from the common ancestors (as shown by similarities and differences with the Cnidarians).  But this is pretty much out of the scope of this post, so we'll defer further discussion for a later time.


RICHARDS, G., SIMIONATO, E., PERRON, M., ADAMSKA, M., VERVOORT, M., & DEGNAN, B.(2008). Sponge Genes Provide New Insight into the Evolutionary Origin of the Neurogenic Circuit Current Biology, 18 (15), 1156-1161 DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2008.06.074

Links: Many of these aren't called out in the text, and too many are behind paywalls.  Use the back key if you came via clicking a footnote.

1.  Conservation of Brachyury, Mef2, and Snail in the Myogenic Lineage of Jellyfish:  A Connection to the Mesoderm of Bilateria

2.  Intracellular Fate Mapping in a Basal Metazoan, the Ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi, Reveals the Origins of Mesoderm and the Existence of Indeterminate Cell Lineages

3.  The Development of Radial and Biradial Symmetry:  The Evolution of Bilaterality

4.  Invertebrate Muscles:  Muscle Specific Genes and Proteins

5.  The Chemical Mechanism of Myosin-I:  Implications for Actin-based Motility and the Evolution of the Myosin Family of Motor Proteins

6.  Evolution of the Heart from Bacteria to Man paywall

7.  Amphink2-tin, an amphioxus homeobox gene expressed in myocardial progenitors:  insights into evolution of the vertebrate heart

8.  Gene Regulatory Networks in the Evolution and Development of the Heart paywall

9.  Phylogenetic relationship of muscle tissues deduced from superimposition of gene trees

10.  Anteroposterior Patterning in Hemichordates and the Origins of the Chordate Nervous System

11.  Centralization of the Deuterostome Nervous System Predates Chordates paywall

12.  The evolution of nervous system centralization

13.  Cnidarians and the evolutionary origin of the nervous system

14.  Sponge Genes Provide New Insight into the Evolutionary Origin of the Neurogenic Circuit paywall

15.  Larval and adult brains paywall

16.  The neuroendocrine system of invertebrates:  a developmental and evolutionary perspective

17.  Central neural circuitry in the jellyfish Aglantha:  a model 'simple nervous system'

18.  A Post-Synaptic Scaffold at the Origin of the Animal Kingdom

19.  Early evolution of animal cell signaling and adhesion genes

20.  The left-right axis in the mouse:  from origin to morphology

21.  A transcriptional regulatory cascade that controls left/right asymmetry in chemosensory neurons of C. elegans
Read more!

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Donate Button: NOT a Solicitation

The new Donate Button was added for the sake of anybody who is "Wowed" by one (or more) of my posts, and really feels like reaching for a checkbook (or whatever). If you're "Wowed", however, there are other ways of showing it, such as posting a link (or writing a post with a link at your own blog) to the article that you liked (as John Wilkins just did). Or adding a comment, especially with references to some peer-reviewed work(s) that apply to the subject. Of course, everybody likes flattery, and money is one of the more sincere forms of flattery: I'm not immune. But there are other forms of flattery.

While the bigger posts are a lot of work, it's fun work and I really do it for my own enjoyment. I also learn a lot doing the research. So I'm pretty well recompensed just in writing the posts. And that's why the button is labeled "If you wish...". Please keep all this in mind. Read more!

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

The Central Nervous System: Meaning and Origin

ResearchBlogging.org
I recently discussed the origin of the nervous system(s), focusing on the earliest neuron:  a cell with an axon that carries an action potential.  Now I want to extend that discussion to the Central Nervous System (CNS), a subject of several recent blog posts (e.g. at Neurophilosophy and NeuroDojo) and a "News Focus" article at Science Magazine.[19] 

It may seem a little strange to be combining "meaning" and "origin" in one discussion:  one is a semantic issue, the other a matter of research.  However, the fact is that research is normally done within a paradigm, and part of what makes up a paradigm is the system of definitions, either tacit or explicit, that allow us to precisely define the meaning of a specific research question.

In my previous post on the subject, I suggested that the original purpose of nerve cells was long distance/high speed communication of chemical state, the early form of what we might call emotions in higher mammals (and perhaps other vertebrates).  The modern descendants of this system in humans and other vertebrates are the autonomic and limbic nervous systems, which carry a large variety of chemical messages throughout the body, at sub-second speed.  Some of these messages pretty much duplicate those of hormones distributed more widely but slowly by the bloodstream, while others are probably restricted to specific areas of the brain that require the information.  In addition, there may be some populations of neurons that carry "region-specific" chemical messages:  where the same chemical "means" something different depending on which area of the brain it's released in.  The dopamine and serotonin systems almost certainly fall into this category (at least in vertebrates).

The CNS in vertebrates is specifically defined as the brain and spinal cord, which are protected by meninges, a series of membranes that separate the cerebrospinal fluid from the bloodstream, and the bony structures of the skull and vertebrae.  This definition has been extended by analogy to such invertebrates as insects, which also have brains and systems of nerve cords.

The CNS and the peripheral nervous system (PNS) together make up the entirety of the vertebrate nervous system.  However, the PNS is divided by function into two very separate systems: the somatic nervous system (SNS) and the autonomic nervous system (ANS).  The SNS extends the CNS to the "voluntary" muscles and external senses, allowing the body to act as a unit in response to external stimuli.  The ANS makes contact with the internal sensory system which monitors such things as the levels of carbon dioxide, oxygen and sugar in the blood, arterial pressure and the chemical composition of the stomach and gut content, and communicates to such organs as the salivatory glands, heart, gut, etc.

Both parts of the PNS actually communicate between the CNS and their target senses and organs.  However, the control of "voluntary" muscles is largely a different system from that of the viscera, even within the brain and spinal cord.  Even though they travel through the spinal cord and are centralized in the brain, these systems are pretty much independent, although they are hooked together at several points.

The visceral parts of the body are mostly connected to the ANS, which communicates (via the spinal cord) with the limbic system in the brain.  This system is often thought of as being concerned with emotions, and it seems to include neurons that produce a much larger number of types of neurotransmitters and neurohormones than the parts associated with control of "voluntary" muscles and overall movement of the body.

Most of the vertebrate brain seems to be dedicated to control of the "voluntary" muscles, which is hardly surprising, since this function requires a lot more precision in location than is needed for communicating chemical information.  It's hardly surprising, therefore, that many more neurons, and a much larger number of connections, is needed for it.

The fact that these systems seem to be fairly independent doesn't mean that they don't communicate in several important ways.  For instance, the limbic system extends axons into the rest of the brain, where it delivers a variety of neurohormones involved with emotional state, allowing all the "voluntary" and "conscious" calculations to use the current emotional state as input.

Nevertheless, the difference between these systems is extremely important, probably much more so than the classical distinction between the CNS and the PNS.

When we look for the origins of the CNS then, we need to begin with a precise definition of what we're looking for.  As mentioned above, the "classical" definition is restricted to vertebrates, and the extension to insects and other invertebrates was by analogy.  Basically, the distinction was anatomical:  nerve cords containing lots of axons and neuropil were considered to constitute CNS, while distributed systems of nerves and ganglia were not.  However, most ganglia contain neuropil, so the distinction is somewhat fuzzy.

When it comes to the actual beginnings of the CNS, we need to be more careful.  Even cnidarians have neuropil,[18] while the acoels, arguably the most basal-branching bilaterians, have a single "ganglion" in their larval form.[16] What are probably the most basal of the eumetazoans, the ctenophores, have a nervous system "composed of a subepidermal nerve net, with neurons concentrated around the mouth and apical organ; there are also nervous elements in the mesoglea, with high concentrations in the tentacles, and near the base of the endoderm (Fig. 1d; [ref])."[17]


Figure 1: Ctenophore body plan and development.  Click on image to see full illustration with caption in article. (From Ref 17.)


Figure 2: Cross-sections of the body wall and brain of Neochildia juvenile.  Muscle fibers are labeled "msf".  Click on image to see original illustration and caption in article.  (From Ref 16 Figure 3.)


What I would propose is to start by excluding the ANS and limbic system from consideration.  While parts of these systems are associated with the CNS, IMO this was purely opportunistic:  a specialized system developed for controlling the muscles, and these nerves moved in too, taking advantage of the protection and supplies of food and oxygen....

Here we need to consider the original system of the common ancestor of the surviving Eumetazoans.  The prevailing view is that the primitive system was a diffuse nerve net, however I've just recently argued that the diffuse nets in the Cnidarians and Ctenophores probably represent specialized adaptations for their lifestyle, and cannot be assumed to represent the ancestral pattern.  If we consider the various small larval forms of the acoels and sponges, lineages that somewhat bracket the forms we're looking at, we find a creature small enough to coordinate its movements with a single bundle of neuropil.

Given this, we can probably suppose a beginning with a single bundle of neuropil, with the muscles extending processes into it to collect control information.  This is consistent with the larval acoel Neochildia fusca, while the adult has a more diffuse structure: 
The size of the brain in juvenile Neochildia is considerable.  Other flatworm taxa possess a ganglion-like brain consisting of a central neuropile surrounded by a cortex of cell bodies.  In adults of Neochildia and other acoel species such a brain has been reported absent.  Instead, neuronal somata and neurites, together with muscle fibers and gland cell processes form a loose reticulated mass at the anterior pole of the animal ([refs]).  However, we find that in late embryos and juveniles of Neochildia, the brain is more compact.  A 3-4 cell-diameter-thick layer of neurons forms a cortex surrounding a central neuropile that is relatively free of cell bodies.  In addition, an "orthogonal" array of muscle fibers penetrates the brain (Fig.  3).[16]
In cnidarians we find a highly sophisticated system for synchronizing muscle activity over long distances.[11] [12] [18]  Most of this sophistication (IMO) is necessary to protect from the poisoning or damage of large areas of the bell during conflicts, however the need for synchronization would be present even without the need for such distributed systems.

In this regard, I want to especially mention a recent paper:  Cnidarians and the evolutionary origin of the nervous system by (Hiroshi Watanabe, Toshitaka Fujisawa, and Thomas W. Holstein).  Here we have a summary of recent research into the localized expression in Cnidarians of genes which, in bilaterians, control the differential development of motor nerves and sensory systems, along with an analysis of the localized development of different types of nerve cell.  This paper provides a useful and very recent survey of what's known regarding the "CNS" of Cnidarians, and the likelihood that it is homologous to that of the Bilaterians: 
Anatomically and physiologically elaborated neural structures observed in cnidaria clearly reflect a considerable degree of regionalization of the cnidarian nervous system.  Although these data have prompted several authors to propose that the nerve ring is the cnidarian CNS ([ref]) that may be even homologous to the bilaterian CNS ([ref]), it still remains unclear whether these regionalized (centralized) neural networks in Cnidaria represent a homologous feature to the CNS of Bilateria.  There is no reason why anatomical features of nerve tracts observed in cnidarians should necessarily be homologous to the CNS of bilaterians.  Even if one accounts for a great degree of physiological complexity observed in the regionalized nervous system and eye-bearing sensory complex (Rhopalia) of cnidarians, an increasing number of examples indicating the evolutionary convergence in both nervous and sensory systems ([ref]) make it difficult to simply compare cnidarian and bilaterian neural structures and to place the evolutionary origin of CNS as commonly discussed ([ref]).  The idea that the rudimentary neural centralization observed in some cnidarians is an antecedent characteristic of the eumetazoan nervous system should be examined at least by comparative molecular analysis.[11]
I should point out that this review was written based on the assumption that the distributed nerve net in Cnidarians (and ctenophores) was primitive.  If, as I have proposed, it is secondary, the possibilities of homology between the concentrations of nerve cells in specific regions and similar concentrations in bilaterians are much more plausible. 

Another consideration has to do with using cilia for swimming.  In general, only the ctenophores among larger animals still use this method, but it was almost certainly the ancestral method for at least normal swimming, with muscles reserved for special situations such as capturing food (e.g. in ctenophores) and escape from predators or natural hazards such as produces by wave action.  The need for nerves to coordinate ciliary action would become increasingly important as size increases, and, unlike muscles, ciliated cells don't naturally have the features needed to coordinate their activity over large areas.  I have suggested that the action potential began as a feature of muscle fibers, to coordinate their activity, and the need for the sort of rapid control over ciliary swimming would probably not have arisen in a small creature, where a slower, more diffuse, system depending on the sort of calcium waves seen in astrocytes might well have been fast enough.

Once larger creatures using coordinated muscle action had evolved, and neurons had evolved to carry the very fast signals needed for this coordination, a somewhat diffuse neural net would probably have been safer than a concentrated cord that would have been vulnerable to a crippling attack.  These creatures probably didn't have the vast redundancies found in Cnidarians, but some redundancy would have been useful, along with spreading out the various nerves so point attacks would have had small effect.

The concentration of nerves into centralized cords, containing neuropil, is generally defined as the beginning of a CNS.  By this definition, many cnidarians posses a CNS, and even the ctenophores have the rudiments of one, although this is mostly a concentration of axons right under the bands of cilia.  This fact, actually, allows us a new approach into the reasons for this concentration:  energy.

Both the transmission of action potentials along axons, and the more analog calculations that take place in the neuropil, require a lot of energy.  There were, basically, two sources of energy for this function in early animals:  burning sugar and the anaerobic process of glycolysis.  Both require a good supply of glucose, or something that can be converted to it (such as fructose).  Fatty acids can also be burned, as can amino acids, but this is unlikely to have been used by the early nerve cells.  In fact, even glycolysis is seldom or never used by most nerve cells,[20] suggesting that it simply doesn't provide enough energy, or perhaps its effect on the internal conditions of the cell (e.g. pH) make it unsuitable.  (Nerve cells can also burn acetoacetate, which is produced by the partial breakdown of triglycerides.  How much this mattered in these early times is hard to fathom.)

In general, then, the source of fuel was glucose, which could be provided without a high-capacity blood flow, because large concentration gradients could be provided.  However, we can assume that extensions of the enteric system were close enough to the surface that sugar could be "pumped" across the enteric membrane into the interior where it would diffuse towards the surface.  That is where the oxygen was, and that is where the original ciliated swimming cells would have been located.  In fact, when we look at the ctenophores, we see that the nerve cords underlie the ciliated cells, which allows them access to oxygen from the moving water (stirred up by the cilia), and also allows supplies of fuel (sugar or whatever) to be provided for both swimming and nervous activity.

This logic is also applicable to the more distributed nerve nets that probably predated the CNS.  Without the ciliary activity, oxygen could be depleted by too many nerve cells or axons in the same place.  Thus, a distributed system of axons and ganglia makes the most sense, until a more centralized and active system of oxygen transport was evolved.

But the fact that this network was distributed doesn't mean it didn't serve the same functions as the CNS:  overall coordinated control of bodily activity that impinges on the external environment:  ciliary activity for swimming and rapid changes to the body's shape for capture of food and escape swimming.  Again, our perceptions of the activity of "diffuse" nervous systems has, IMO, been distorted by looking at the cnidarians, because their massively redundant cross-connected networks have been perceived as primitive, rather than a secondary adaptation to their lifestyle.

I would suggest that the original system for communicating chemical state, ancestral to the ANS and the limbic system, was also sufficient for controlling the various regions of ciliated cells that did the swimming.  A few disparate signal chemicals would have been sufficient to communicate desired speed, direction, and twisting/turning, and a distributive network for each dimension of this 6- to 10-dimensional vector would have required no more cells than the modern ANS.  Each ciliated cell could have computed for itself the required response to the vector, using separate receptors for each chemical signal, and independently calculating its response based on its knowledge of its position on the body.

It's with muscles that things become more complex.  Muscular activity in many places must be coordinated across the entire body, which requires some sort of "centralized" headquarters, with its calculations being distributed to the various muscles involved.  As mentioned above, for small animals, all that's needed a simple bundle of neuropil with the muscles directly extending processes into it to acquire their directions.  As the animal gets larger, extensions of the nerve cells that end up calculating the required activity for each group of muscle fibers could reach out to the muscles themselves, and their reach could be extended by branching systems or redundant networks of nerve cells that act as simple relays:  passing along the actions potentials just as received without calculation:  perhaps even using direct electrical connections to transfer the action potential from one cell to another.

As the centralized, whole-body activity was supplemented by local responses to local stimuli, the need for local calculations could be met by local ganglia:  concentrations of nerve cells and neuropil that could calculate the appropriate response to a local stimulus in view of the current directions coming from the central headquarters.  Thus, we can see that the SNS may well have developed after the first rudimentary CNS.  This also allows us to refine our definition of the CNS:  It consists of the neurons and associated cells that act as the "central headquarters" for calculating the whole-body activity in response to external stimuli and internal conditions.  The SNS, by contrast, can be redefined as the system of local ganglia that calculate local response(s) to local stimuli, integrating them into the whole-body directions.  This definition is independent of whether these systems are concentrated into "nerve cords", which is probably more a function of the need for oxygen.

This can also allow us to estimate the time that the original CNS arose:  when the systems of muscles became complex enough to require coordinated activity, while the size was too large to allow each muscle fiber to extend its own process into the central bundle of neuropil that functioned as a "brain".  In fact, as we saw above, many adult acoels probably fit this definition, and despite the fact that they have no "nerve cords", and the "neuronal somata and neurites, together with muscle fibers and gland cell processes [that] form a loose reticulated mass at the anterior pole of the animal"[16] would not be defined as a CNS according to the traditional definition, I think we should allow it according to the definition I have proposed.  Given that such a system is present in both cnidarians and ctenophores, I would propose that the origin of the CNS should be placed prior to the first divergence of these groups.


Hiroshi Watanabe, Toshitaka Fujisawa, and Thomas W. Holstein (2009). Cnidarians and the evolutionary origin of the nervous system Development, Growth & Differentiation, 51 (3), 167-183 DOI: 10.1111/j.1440-169X.2009.01103.x

Links: (I've only included the links called out in this leader.) Not all of these are called out in the text.  Use the back key if you came via a footnote.


1.  Anteroposterior Patterning in Hemichordates and the Origins of the Chordate Nervous System

2.  Centralization of the Deuterostome Nervous System Predates Chordates paywall

3.  Defining a neuron:  neuronal ELAV proteins paywall

4.  Brain Size:  A Global or Induced Cost of Learning?

5.  Gene Duplication, Co-Option and Recruitment during the Origin of the Vertebrate Brain from the Invertebrate Chordate Brain paywall

6.  Rapid functional diversification in the structurally conserved ELAV family of neuronal RNA binding proteins
(Requires free registration)

7.  The interplay of nuclear mRNP assembly, mRNA surveillance and export paywall

8.  Post-transcriptional operons and regulons co-ordinating gene expression (Galley copy:  for the published article behind the paywall, go here.)

9.  Regulation of mRNA stability in mammalian cells paywall (2001=old)

10.  The evolution of nervous system centralization

11.  Cnidarians and the evolutionary origin of the nervous system

12.  Anatomy and development of the nervous system of Nematostella vectensis, an anthozoan cnidarian paywall

13.  The neuroendocrine system of invertebrates:  a developmental and evolutionary perspective

14.  Development of the insect stomatogastric nervous system

15.  Larval and adult brains paywall


16.  Embryonic development in the primitive bilaterian Neochildia fusca:  normal morphogenesis and isolation of POU genes Brn-1 and Brn-3

17.  Developmental expression of homeobox genes in the ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi

18.  Bilateral symmetric organization of neural elements in the visual system of a coelenterate, Tripedalia cystophora (Cubozoa) paywall

19.  On the Origin of The Nervous System paywall

20.  Energy Substrates for Neurons During Neural Activity:  A Critical Review of the Astrocyte-Neuron Lactate Shuttle Hypothesis
Read more!

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Coelenterates, Cnidarians, and Larvae

ResearchBlogging.org
The Cnidarians are a major, basally-branching, clade within the Eumetazoans, with strong similarities among themselves as well as differences.  They have two archetypal body forms, the polyp and the medusa, and most lineages show an "alternation of generations", with medusae reproducing sexually to produce eggs that develop into polyps, which in turn bud off a succession of immature medusae, a form of asexual "reproduction".  One of the shared features among them are cnidocytes (also called cnidoblasts, or nematocytes), poisonous harpoon-like cells that are used to capture prey and in various types of conflict.

One of the differences among the various lineages involves these two body forms:  the Anthozoa lack a medusa form at all (as do various groups among other lineages), while the cubozoans undergo something much more reminiscent of a tadpole's metamorphosis into a frog:  much or most of the polyp's body mass is taken up into a single medusa.  This does not in any way constitute "reproduction", and in an earlier post I've argued that we should not regard the creation of multiple clones with the same genome as "reproduction" either:  "reproduction" (among Eukaryotes) should be limited to the creation of new individual genomes, while the creation of new organisms with the same genome should be regarded as a form of "growth" of the individual.  (Thus equating the individual with the genome.  One commenter suggested "proliferation", at least with regard to single-celled organisms.)


Figure 1:  Polyp (From Wiki)


Figure 2:  Medusae (drawings by Haeckel; From Wiki)


Now, most (or at least many) Cnidarians have a "larval" form that develops quickly from the fertilized egg, and swims around a bit until it finds a spot to anchor and metamorphose into a polyp.  In my view, however, calling this form a "larva" represents a misuse of the term that has led to an implausible, or at least improbable, picture of the origin and early evolution of the Cnidarians, with unfortunate results for the more general pictures of metazoan origins, especially when it comes to their nervous systems.  ...

The typical Cnidarian "larvae" is a small, biradial, planula, usually non-feeding (although in some species it does do some eating).

This in contrast to the classic larvae we normally think of:  insects and (vertebrate) amphibians.  In the older clades of insects, the newly hatched nymphs bear some resemblance to the adult, although lacking wings.  During their successive molts they become more adult-like, until in their final molt (next to final among mayflies) they have wings and are ready to reproduce.  (In mayflies the penultimate molt, called subimago or to fly fishermen a dun, has wings, but only the final molt reproduces.) Examples include dragonflies, grasshoppers, roaches/termites, and preying mantises.

One insect clade, the Holometabola, invented the worm-like larva, a juvenile body form specialized for very rapid growth through a large size range:  as much as 100,000 times larger at the final molt than when hatched.  This larva has a simplified body, depending on easily expanded coeloms for support, and capable of expanding quite far in each molt.  It has little or no resemblance to the adult form, although in some beetles the head comes to resemble the adult during the final few molts.

While the frogs and salamanders don't generally achieve the level of size increase found in many insects, their tadpoles are also well adapted for great expansion, with the legs only developing at something close to the adult size.  As with the Holometabolous insects, then, the primary advantage of the larva is the ability to grow very rapidly during a short period when food is over-abundant, while the more sophisticated body plans of insect nymphs and juvenile amniotes grow more slowly, because they require more time and energy to modify their structure during size increase.  Another issue is that their body plans are more specialized with regard to size:  the square-cube law puts limitations on how far a single body plan can expand before it becomes too heavy for its support structures.  (For this reason, creatures that live in water don't face as many problems with very large size increases as land creatures.)

When we compare these classic larvae with the "larvae" of Cnidarians, there is an obvious difference:  the latter don't do much if any size expansion.  In fact, according to the logic of insects and amphibians, it is the polyp form that represents the closest thing to a larva possessed by Cnidarians.  This is especially true for those lineages that bud off multiple clones in medusa form, although the metamorphosis of the cubozoans is so reminiscent of frogs that it certainly brings the parallel to mind.

Moreover, the Anthozoa, which lack a medusa form, might well be compared to the axolotl, which is capable of undergoing sexual reproduction in larval form under some circumstances (although it retains a land-living adult form, unlike the Anthozoa).  This process, in which a larval form acquires the ability to reproduce and loses the adult form, is a form of neoteny, a process which has been overused, in my view, in models of early animal evolution.  Nevertheless, this is a case where I think it applies, contra the prevailing view of Cnidarian origins.

This prevailing view is that the polyp form is the ancestral form of the Cnidarian, with the early-branching Anthozoa having separated from the rest before their lineage developed the medusa form.[2] In contrast, I would model the ancestral Cnidarian as a medusa already possessing a polypoid larva, which, like insect and amphibian larvae has been secondarily simplified while evolving its specializations for rapid massive growth.  Just as the larvae of insects don't really resemble their immediate ancestors, although they have some similarities to more ancient ancestors, and just as the tadpole (lacking e.g. limbs) doesn't really resemble the immediate ancestors of the first land tetrapods, the polyp form doesn't (IMO) really represent the ancestral form of the medusa, but rather is a very simplified form with a few similarities to an ancestral form.

Why should we find an entire clade of very basally-branching Eumetazoans descended from such a highly specialized form?  My answer begins with the distinction between coelenterates and cnidarians.  The term coelenterate means an animal that uses its stomach (enteric system) as a coelom:  an internal vessel filled with liquid under pressure that can do duty as a skeleton.  I have suggested in the past that a fully formed coelom, with a complete epithelial system and muscles capable of compressing it in appropriate directions, is a much more sophisticated type of skeleton than is usually modeled, and in this case I would suggest that the coelenterates evolved by first developing a sphincter to close their gut against pressure, then developing the muscles and nerve control necessary to use it as a skeleton.  (The early bilaterians, in my model, lacked such sphincters, as do the modern acoels, and only after various lineages had developed pass-through guts did they develop sphincters to close them off.)

In my view, then, the lineage leading to the Cnidarians started by becoming coelenterates, and underwent one or more massive explosions of adaptive radiation, creating a very large and diverse clade.  Most of these were biradial, as were the original ancestors of the Ctenophores and the bilaterians.  Some developed radial symmetry with higher indices than two, one of these being the ancestors of the Cnidarians.

It is the cnidocytes that set this lineage off from all the other coelenterates, and with the development of vertebrates (and various invertebrate clades) with more compact body plans, and more complex nervous systems dependent on greater circulation, the Cnidarians underwent their own massive expansion due to their excellent adaptation to preying on them, producing the lineages that survive today, along perhaps with a few that joined all the other coelenterates in extinction when out-competed by vertebrates and highly evolved invertebrates such as the arthropods and cephalopods.

There are several reasons that I consider my model much more plausible than the prevailing view.  First, as I mentioned, the polyp form fits almost perfectly into the "classic" definition of larvae, as possessed by the Holometabolous insects and amphibians.  Indeed, if not for the classification of the planula as "the" larval form, I suspect the polyp would have been assigned this role a long time ago.  (Of course, the Cnidarians could have been defined as using hypermetamorphosis.)

Another reason is that the cnidocytes are a highly sophisticated adaptation, shared among all lineages of cnidarian.  In my view, their development is extremely unlikely to have occurred simultaneously with the coelenterate adaptations, and if they had evolved first, it seems likely that some descendants would still be around, although I realize that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.  There could have been reasons that all the non-coelenterate cnidarians died out, although the existence of the Ctenophores argues against it.  (The Ctenophores do not have a pressurized gut, although they do have the probably ancestral hollow gut they share with coelenterates and acoels.)

If the coelenterates developed first, they almost certainly would have undergone an explosion of adaptive radiation, considering that the ancestral bilaterians probably had not yet developed very far.  It's worth considering that if, as I believe, the earliest feature that did service as a skeleton was a somewhat elastic structure right under the epidermis, sharing the features of cartilage and muscle, the addition of a high-pressure coelom would have allowed a massive increase in size, without much loss of ability to change body shape through muscular action.  By contrast, the ctenophores, which retain such a skeleton and lack a coelom, have little ability to change shape, except for their tentacles, and they swim by means of cilia.

These three reasons are sufficient, IMO, to make this model far superior to one in which the ancestral Cnidarian was a polyp with cnidocytes, which then developed the medusa form.  This, in turn, has important implications for metazoan evolution in general.  The medusa form is much more sophisticated, with its water canals constituting a fairly complex skeleton,[7] [9] a full-fledged neuroendocrine system,[4] and a nervous system adapted to working with the skeleton to control swimming.[1] [2] [7] [9] Many refinements have been developed by individual lineages,[3] however it's very plausible that the common ancestor had the rudiments of most of them.

In this regard, I want to discuss a recent paper, Control of swimming in the hydrozoan jellyfish Aequorea victoria:  subumbrellar organization and local inhibition (by Richard A. Satterlie).  Here we have a report of multiple nerve nets serving different functions, linked by both chemical synapses and gap junctions.  Both muscle and epithelial cells participate in the distribution of action potentials.  The overall systems of control in various cnidarians is quite complex and sophisticated: 
As a final word on the swimming system of hydromedusae, the organization of the motor network of the inner nerve ring is influenced by parallel sensory networks of the inner and outer nerve rings ([refs]).  Furthermore, fourteen distinct conducting systems have been described in Aglantha ([ref]).  In Aequorea, multiple statocysts are found throughout the bell margin ([ref]), and righting responses to tilt involve asymmetrical swimming contractions of the subumbrella, possibly including the local inhibitory mechanisms discussed here.  These observations suggest that parallel and point-source pathways provide excitatory or inhibitory input to the swim motor network in the inner nerve ring of hydromedusae, pointing to an integrative organization that forms what can be argued to be a true central nervous system in these radially symmetrical organisms.  In these animals, the `primitive' condition of diffuse, non-directional nerve nets has been modified in some conducting systems into a series of compressed, function-specific nerve networks that interact in the complex neural structures of the inner and outer nerve rings.  As an example of the richness of function of the hydromedusan nervous system, one has to look no further than the organization of Aglantha ([ref]) to be impressed with the neural complexity of this `simple' animal group.
Note that these conclusions are based on the prevailing view that the cnidarians began as a "simple" creature with a "simple" nervous system.  In my view, the distributed nervous system isn't "simple" at all, but a sophisticated adaption to the cnidarian lifestyle, especially in terms of intra-specific territorial conflict (see below).  Thus, we can plausibly model the cnidarian ancestor as having a fully functional central nervous system of sorts.

In this model, once the stem lineage had perfected the cnidocyte, various lineages of Cnidarian diverged along several paths.  The cubozoans retained the ancestral metamorphosis, while refining their ability to see and control their swimming in the medusa form.  They have surprisingly complex nervous systems.[6] [8] (They also have the most powerful poisons, in general.) The Anthozoa, and multiple lineages within other clades, have undergone neoteny and lost the medusa form, building on the polypoid ability for rapid and massive growth.  Most of the lineages ended up with a multiplier for their larval form, in that they produce a large number of medusoid clones, allowing them to adapt to longer local seasons of over-abundance.

What we must consider is that the polyp, as a larva rather than a retained ancestral form, represents a reversion (in some respects) to a very ancient ancestor:  quite likely the common ancestor of the ctenophores, cnidarians, and bilaterians, and not necessarily the latest one at that.  This means we can't use it as a measure of the sophistication of even the earliest ancestor of the coelenterates, especially when it comes to the nervous system.  The specializations sufficient to control a medusoid form may well have been present in the last common ancestor of the bilaterians and coelenterates, and some of them may have been present in the last common ancestor of the ctenophores, coelenterates, and bilaterians, as well.

In addition, we must consider one of the key features of the coelenterates, their distributed nerve nets.  These have been used to justify the assumption that this sort of nervous system was present in the common ancestor, but in fact these distributed nets are most likely adaptations to intraspecific conflict using cnidocytes.  The process of evolving these highly adapted structures was almost certainly accompanied by territorial conflicts between individuals, and as they became better adapted for capturing prey, they also provided an increasing selective advantage for nerve nets that could suffer massive temporary shutdowns under the influence of the toxins involved.  This allows us to paint a completely different picture of the nervous systems of the earliest animals.

It might be argued that the ctenophores have a mostly distributed nervous system as well, but we should note that they, also, probably represent the result of adaptive radiation from a single ancestor adapted to preying on coelenterates.  Most of them retain this adaptation.  It seems most plausible to me that the ctenophores co-evolved with their prey, acquiring and refining the ability to withstand the poisonous cnidocytes as their prey acquired and refined the cnidocytes.  While part of this adaptation involved immunity to poisons, another part involved a more distributed nerve net.  Another adaptation is their simplified structure, which does not reflect their rather sophisticated gene expression patterns.[5]

The bottom line, then, is that when we look more carefully at the definitions and use of the word "larva", we can see a completely different, and potentially much more sophisticated, picture of the last common ancestor of the surviving Eumetazoans.


Satterlie, R. (2008). Control of swimming in the hydrozoan jellyfish Aequorea victoria: subumbrellar organization and local inhibition Journal of Experimental Biology, 211 (21), 3467-3477 DOI: 10.1242/jeb.018952

Links: Some of these aren't called out in the text.  Unfortunately, too many of the most interesting are behind paywalls, I've done what I could to include open access articles covering the important points.

1.  The evolution of nervous system centralization

2.  Cnidarians and the evolutionary origin of the nervous system

3.  Anatomy and development of the nervous system of Nematostella vectensis, an anthozoan cnidarian paywall

4.  The neuroendocrine system of invertebrates:  a developmental and evolutionary perspective

5.  Developmental expression of homeobox genes in the ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi

6.  Bilateral symmetric organization of neural elements in the visual system of a coelenterate, Tripedalia cystophora (Cubozoa) paywall

7.  Control of swimming in the hydrozoan jellyfish Aequorea victoria:  subumbrellar organization and local inhibition

8.  Rhopalia are integrated parts of the central nervous system in box jellyfish paywall

9.  Central neural circuitry in the jellyfish Aglantha:  a model 'simple nervous system'
Read more!

Monday, July 6, 2009

Science Pro Publica #7 is Up


Here.


Lots of good stuff there, including one of my better efforts. Read more!

Thursday, July 2, 2009

Carnival of Evolution is Up

Here. Two of my posts are in it, but you've probably already read them. Check out the carnival to see what's there you haven't read. Read more!

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

(Not So) Open Access

I've been going through my posts, checking out some of the references there for subjects of future posts, and I discovered a footnote link that I couldn't get into, although I'd read it before.  Just now, I discovered another, and fixed it (Note 6 in "Modularity Part I: Metabolic Pathways").  What a nuisance.

I'm going to go through my back posts, as I get time, and fix any others, most of which (IIRC) are in Science (magazine).  Meanwhile, here's a trick you can use for most (hopefully all) of the Science links like this in my posts, and likely a great number of other older articles there.

  1. Go to HighWire Press, which will bring up a search screen (if it doesn't, you'll have to navigate around the site till you find one).

  2. Paste the title of the article you want to read into the field labeled Anywhere in Text:, and click on the phrase selector.

  3. Click the Search button.

  4. Scan down the resulting list of articles until you find one with a "this article is FREE" panel under it.  To be fair, you should pick a free article related to the reason you want to read one you're after.  (Even better if you want to read it too.)

  5. Click on the Full text link at the right (the PDF won't work, if that's all there is, you need another choice).

  6. Drop down to the footnotes, and find the one for the title you're after.  (I normally use a text search in the browser.)

  7. If there's a link for "Free full text", click it.  If there isn't, you'll have to try another.  (I've always seen one so far.)

So far, this has worked for me, although most of the papers were those I followed free text links to before, and only with Science.  And only with older papers.

Of course, this may not work forever.  And there may be other tricks needed with other publishers, although it may work for articles in other magazines published by HighWire.  I guess it depends how eager you are to read an article, how much effort you'll put into finding a way to it without paying.  It's different for me, since I need to make them available to readers. Read more!

Monday, June 29, 2009

The Origin of the Nervous System(s)

ResearchBlogging.org
Most of us know what a nerve cell is, at least generally.  It usually consists of a soma (body) with dendrites that collect information, and an axon that carries information about when the cell fires an action potential to other cells, often over long distances.  But how and when did the neuron evolve?  How did the various systems that use neurons evolve?  How much and what kind of communication did the animals before nerves use, and for what? 

I'm going to address these questions in this post, starting with the model I proposed earlier: 

Thus, we have a small ball of cells, with a bunch of collared flagella, probably in front, ciliated cells along the equator, and some sort of sensory abilities. 

[...]

It's completely plausible, IMO, that a small animal like a floating sponge might have had a system of internal water-canals, while still having a regular shape and the ability to swim.  Thus, each lineage would have branched off from the main line (with swimming adults), then developed a sessile lifestyle. 

[...]

It may well be that there was a steady progression of advance in developmental mechanisms, with one lineage of sponges branching off after each advance.  Thus, the last branch, the Homoscleromorpha, would have had almost the full suite of mechanisms, probably including biradial symmetry. 

[...]

Finally, let me mention communication. It seem unlikely that this animal had nerve cells (although it's been suggested[1]), however much of the cellular machinery needed for chemical communication is present in at least some lineages of sponges.[1] [I've updated the footnotes.]

So the question is, sort of internal communication did this animal have, and what was the path followed by the lineages leading to the eumetazoan nerve cell?  ... Before we address that question, however, we need to take a closer look at the animal involved, and it's evolution.

The Nature of the Urmetazoan

I've mentioned the way we can look at the paraphyly of the sponges and what it can tell us regarding the progressive evolution of the various improvements found in the eumetazoans relative to what we normally see in (adult) sponges.[2] Quoting from the referenced paper:
[...] The demonstration that Porifera is paraphyletic and therefore represents an evolutionary grade has important implications for the polarization of character states and understanding the sequence of character acquisition at the base of Metazoa.

Metazoa (Fig. 2, node 1) is characterized, in part, by the acquisition of multicellularity and the presence of the extracellular matrix, a complex of collagen, proteoglycan, adhesive glycoprotein and integrin, which mediates cell motility and transitions between epithelial and motile cell types ([ref]). Because of sponge paraphyly, the WCS [water channel system] with choanocytes (itself a likely plesiomorphic cell type), had also evolved by this point as well. The unnamed clade Calcarea + Epitheliozoa (epitheliozoans are the homoscleromorph + eumetazoans, see below) (Fig. 2, node 2) is potentially characterized by the presence of cross-striated rootlets. Most metazoan ciliated cells have a system of cross-striated rootlets that originates in the ciliary basal body and extends into the cytoplasm. Calcisponge larvae, as well as those of homoscleromorphs, have long, crossstriated cell rootlets ([refs]) that were perhaps incorporated into adult eumetazoans through neotenous evolution ([ref]). However, the choanoflagellate [arguably the closest relative to the metazoans, see here] Monosiga, the placozoan Trichoplax, as well as several other protistan taxa, also have striated rootlets ([refs]) implying that either the rootlets of Calcarea + Epitheliozoa are not homologous with those of choanoflagellates or this trait is plesiomorphic for Metazoa and has been secondarily lost in Hexactinellida and Demospongiae.

The clade Homoscleromorpha + Eumetazoa is herein recognized as Epitheliozoa (Fig. 2, node 3). Ax ([ref]) defined the clade Epitheliozoa for the clade of epithelial animals, and it is usually considered to include Ctenophora, Cnidaria and triploblasts (e.g. [ref]). The position of the homoscleromorphs as the sister taxa to Eumetazoa, as well as the presence of basal laminae ([refs]), suggests that the Epitheliozoa should include the Homoscleromorpha. A second potential apomorphy of the Epitheliozoa is the presence of an acrosome ([refs]). Thus, of the four primary eumetazoan characters—tissues, an acrosome, a nervous system and a gut—the acquisition of tissues and the acrosome antedated the last common ancestor of homoscleromorphs and eumetazoans. The expression of features such as epithelia in the adult, along with the acquisition of these new characters (nervous system and gut), and the loss of the WCS, could be due to a coordinated character change ([ref]) accompanying the neotenous evolution of a non-feeding sponge larva to a predatory eumetazoan.[2]

Let's take a look at what that means, given our model of a small, free-swimming spheroidal animal with internal water canals:

Figure 1: Summary of discussion points from quoted paper. (Original)


  1. Node 1:  Metazoa:

    1. multicellularity

    2. extracellular matrix

    3. WCS (Water Canal System) with choanocytes

    4. post-synaptic protein homologs[1] (see below)

  2. Node 2:  Calcarea + Epitheliozoa:

    1. cross-striated rootlets

  3. Node 3:  Epitheliozoa:

    1. basal laminae

    2. acrosome

    3. developmental cell signaling and adhesion genes[4] (see below)

    4. Runx genes encoding proteins that bear at their C-terminus a WRPY sequence, which functions to recruit the Groucho/TLE corepressor[3] (see below)


As you can see, according to Sperling et al., the metazoa already possessed the water canal system and the extra-cellular matrix. The primary development leading to the next mode was cross-striated rootlets, although there is considerable doubt about this development. Finally, the epithelium characterizes the final node that includes modern sponges. Each of these nodes, then, presumably underwent an adaptive radiation as free-swimming animals after refining its development(s), but only a few sessile, benthic, lineages survived when the next radiation came. Only the Eumetazoans actually had free-swimming lineages that survive today.

Figure 2: Sequences of adaptive radiations associated with proposed nodes:  1:  Metazoa, 2:  Calcarea + Epitheliozoa, 3:  Epitheliozoa, 4:  Eumetazoa. (Original, replaced earlier version 7/01/09.)


We can imagine that the original animal, then, had refined its system of water canals, using cilia to swim and some sort of visual and olfactory (chemotaxic) system to steer, allowing it to chase down the populations of bacteria or other food they required. The development of cross-striated rootlets probably allowed the skin-mounted cilia to apply greater pressure to the water as they pushed it, permitting greater size and speed. The development of the epithelia allowed the extra-cellular area to be kept under pressure relative to the surroundings.

An important difference with Sperling et al. is that I'm assuming that the common ancestor's adult form was free-swimming, and that as each lineage evolved a sessile, benthic lifestyle, it also (independently) acquired a larval form with some vestigial characteristics of the ancestral adult.

Internal Communications

Quoting again from the model I proposed earlier: 
If this model is true, our most distant ancestor might have had a fairly sophisticated system of communication long before the invention of nerve cells. It would be directly ancestral to our modern system of chemical emotions, and may have been even more sophisticated, since there were no nerve cells to handle more "digital" types of calculation. Indeed, the chemical intelligence displayed by modern vertebrates in controlling their development may well have been used to control active behavior in this ancient ancestor.
Note here that the presence of a full epithelium permits isolating those chemical communications from the outside, as well as potentially compartmentalizing chemical communications into separate modules.

In three recent post, Nerve Cells and Glial Cells: Redefining the Foundation of Intelligence, Beyond the Synapse, and The Analog Axon, I discussed the large variety of inter-cell communications that don't depend on action potentials flowing along the axon. Not only nerve cells, but at least one, and likely two, types of glial cells can fire action potentials, although they may not do so in vivo. Even without action potentials, voltage variations in cell membranes can carry signals created by chemical signals from other cells. Small patches of cell membrane can act as semi-independent calculators, responding to local conditions with local releases of various transmitters. These conditions include voltage, but also the local concentrations of all sorts of signal molecules on both sides of the cell membrane.

It would be easy to assume that the sophisticated communications just mentioned evolved after the neuron did, but it's more plausible that they were there first, and that the action potential evolved later, as a high-speed, long-distance mechanism for carrying a small subset of time-dependent control information. Thus, we can assume that, by the time the ancestors of the eumetazoans diverged from those of the Homoscleromorphs, much of the system of calculation used in the modern brain was already present, at least in rudimentary form. In this regard, we may note that many of the genes used in brain communications appear to have already been present in even the early nodes.[1]

This type of calculation/communication is energy intensive, so it's quite likely that the original cells to undertake this process were ectodermal, since such cells would have had the best access to external oxygen. They may well have started by extending small processes toward other cells through the extra-cellular matrix, from which they released transmitters carrying their current message.

It is with the development of the epithelium (Node 3) that things really took off. Both the descendant lineages of this node appear to possess the full complement of developmental cell signaling and adhesion genes.[4] In addition, a very recent paper,[3] The evolution of Runx genes II. The C-terminal Groucho recruitment motif is present in both eumetazoans and homoscleromorphs but absent in a haplosclerid demosponge (by Anthony J Robertson, Claire Larroux, Bernard M Degnan and James A Coffman), demonstrates that a specific pair of genes that already existed in ancestral animals were linked in the common ancestor of node 3 but not before.

These two genes, between them, occupy a key position in controlling cell differentiation, and the fact that they are present at this node strongly suggests that the free-swimming ancestors had a complex organization of their bodies. Since the organization of internal water channels probably doesn't require this, the best hypothesis (IMO) is that is was required to organize the communication system.

For an animal a few millimeters long, this system probably didn't require the speed of the action potential, but the complex calculations possible to an organized structure of differentiated cells would have (potentially) made this a quite smart little animal. It seems very plausible to me that the primary advantage of the sophisticated system of developmental control was its ability to support the development of this powerful system of calculation and communication, long before it could gain the advantage of more complex bodies.

The Action Potential

It isn't only neurons that have sophisticated adaptions to carry action potentials, muscle cells do as well.[5] In fact, they may well have had them first, since they would need synchronized activity over their entire lengths. Most likely the signal speed of action potentials would not even be needed until there were muscles to respond to them, and muscle fibers are so large in comparison to axons that they could have extended a process to the appropriate calculating cell more cheaply than the cell could have done to them.

We can see the neural action potential evolving, then, as the specializations already present in muscle cells are adopted by nerve cells for high-speed communication.

Rather than control of muscles, I suspect that the original value of the neural action potential was to communicate overall chemical "emotional" state: the rudiments of the modern peripheral nervous system. Once the structure of the nerve cell was fully refined, it was then adopted to the control of muscles, a process that probably wasn't complete until the early bilaterians.


Robertson, A., Larroux, C., Degnan, B., & Coffman, J. (2009). The evolution of Runx genes II. The C-terminal Groucho recruitment motif is present in both eumetazoans and homoscleromorphs but absent in a haplosclerid demosponge BMC Research Notes, 2 (1) DOI: 10.1186/1756-0500-2-59

Links: (Some of these are duplicates of links from earlier posts. Not all have been called out in the text. Many are derived from the main article. Use the back key if you came via clicking a footnote.) (I've included only the link referenced in this leader.)

1.  A Post-Synaptic Scaffold at the Origin of the Animal Kingdom



2.  Poriferan paraphyly and its implications for Precambrian palaeobiology

3.  The evolution of Runx genes II. The C-terminal Groucho recruitment motif is present in both eumetazoans and homoscleromorphs but absent in a haplosclerid demosponge

4.  Early evolution of animal cell signaling and adhesion genes

5.  t-tubules and sarcoplasmic reticulum function in cardiac ventricular myocytes
Read more!