Monday, August 3, 2009

Neocortex, Allocortex, and Nuclei, and the Remapping of Their Connections

ResearchBlogging.org
The mammalian brain is made up of many parts, each pretty much unique.  However, these various parts, or at least the "gray matter" of them, can be roughly grouped into three classes of structure, or even more roughly into two: nucleus and cortex.  The word "cortex" comes from the Latin, meaning "bark", "rind", "shell" or "husk".  In the case of gray matter, it usually denotes a relatively thin layer of gray matter covering thicker white: such as the neocortex, the piriform cortex, or many other cortical areas in mammals and other vertebrates.  In a recent post, I described the neocortex, comparing and contrasting it with other forms, which are loosely grouped together as "allocortex".  (Meaning "other cortex" with a connotation for "other" of "like but not identical".  This from the Greek prefix "allo-" which we may contrast with the alternative prefix "hetero-" which means "unlike".)

The class of structure I haven't touched on yet is the nucleus: defined by Wiki as "a brain structure consisting of a relatively compact cluster of neurons." Quoting further:
The term "nucleus" is in some cases used rather loosely, to mean simply an identifiably distinct group of neurons, even if they are spread over an extended area.  The reticular nucleus of the thalamus, for example, is a thin layer of inhibitory neurons that surrounds the thalamus.
In this respect, the word parallels "allocortex", which also covers a variety of forms.  Only the Neocortex has a very precise description, and even here only by excluding the parts of the hippocampus in which neurons mature from the outside in as they do in the neocortex.  In addition, the cortical structure of the Cerebellum should probably be given its own term, considering the very old and very sophisticated developmental mechanisms unique to it.  I'm not going to discuss the Cerebellum in this post, it deserves its own, along with more detailed research than I've done to date on its evolution.

In several posts, I've discussed the general nature of the "gray matter", focusing on "neuropil", which is generally defined as a tangled mass of neurites, glial and sometimes neural somas, and glial extensions (which would be called neurites if they were possessed by neurons rather than glia).  The neuropil is where the real work of calculation takes place, since is contains most of the active dendritic arbor (one way or another) as well as most of the synapses and a goodly part of the axonic arbor.  The relationship between the mass of neural somas and the neuropil varies by region of the brain, being different in at least some details for just about each region studied.

In many parts of the brain and Central Nervous System (CNS) a set of similar structures call glomeruli turn up.  These have been extensively studied and described in the olfactory system, where they are part of the olfactory bulb, which forms a "way station" of sorts between the olfactory epithelium which contains the actual sensory cells, and the deeper parts of the brain, including the piriform cortex and the amygdala and hypothalamus.

Glomeruli have also been studied in the cerebellum (Wiki only describes them in these two spots, as well as superficially similar structures in the kidney), but studies have been made of similar structures in many places in the CNS, including, for instance, the trigeminal nucleus.[1]  In general, a glomerulus can be described as a tangle of neuropil surrounded by a tighter structure of neural and glial somas cells with extensions of both into the central part.  In many (perhaps most) types of glomeruli, diffusion of neurohormones through the central part is easy and fast enough that most of the neurites inhabit the same extracellular concentrations of signaling molecules, at least on a time-scale of seconds or more.  The tight structure of the surrounding cell bodies, along with (presumably) greater uptake rates by glial cell membranes, would tend to isolate the concentrations within any one glomerulus from even its nearest neighbors.  In contrast to the typical neuropil of the neocortex, where concentrations of emitted extra-synaptic neurohormones might vary over micron scales or less, it seems likely that the extra-synaptic concentrations of glomeruli are pretty much normalized.

All of these brain structures depend on the axon bundles (called "tracts" in the brain, although they are called "nerves" in the periphery, per Wiki) to transmit information between the more detailed calculations in the neuropil.  ... Indeed, in the more traditional view, the primary calculation was simply whether/when to fire an action potential, which was regarded as the key to the brain's activity.  Recent research has thoroughly undercut this view, as I've discussed in several posts.  However, even with this new information, the "wiring" of axonal connections is critical to the working of the brain.

Which brings us to a very important research paper,[13] published in last Friday's Science Magazine: Pre-Target Axon Sorting Establishes the Neural Map Topography (by Takeshi Imai, Takahiro Yamazaki, Reiko Kobayakawa, Ko Kobayakawa, Takaya Abe, Misao Suzuki, and Hitoshi Sakano).  This paper is, unfortunately, behind a paywall, but I'm going to describe the finding in general terms, then go on to its importance, especially in terms of how we can generalize from the olfactory system to the brain in general.

We need to start with a brief description of how the olfactory sense in mammals works: it begins with the olfactory epithelium, which is a structure inside the nose, where mucus with absorbed volatiles comes in contact with olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs).  (There is a organ called the vomeronasal organ which is the input to the accessory olfactory system which I'm not going to discuss here.)  Each OSN expresses one specific odorant receptor (OR), of which there are around a thousand in mice, rabbits, and other mammals that have retained the ancestral focus on this sense.  (Humans have about 350.[23])  Actually, this is the number of genes, there are two copies, one from each parent, and any specific cell only expresses one of those copies.[13] 

The distribution of OSNs expressing any one OR within the olfactory epithelium tends to be quite specific, pretty much identical from one member of a species to another.  Although the surface of the olfactory epithelium is rather convoluted, it can be unfolded into a roughly planar surface, extending from dorsomedial (upper/inner) to ventrolateral (lower/outer) in one dimension, and anterior to posterior (front to back) in the other.  The OSNs expressing a specific OR will all lie in a rather narrow stripe extending all the way from anterior to posterior, but only a small part of the dorsomedial to ventrolateral dimension.[13] 

Now, as mentioned above, the olfactory bulb serves as a "way station" between the olfactory epithelium and the deeper (higher) regions of the brain.  What happens is that there's one glomerulus (on each side) in the olfactory bulb for each specific OR, and axons from all the OSN's expressing that OR end up at that glomerulus.  The surface of the olfactory bulb, like the olfactory epithelium, can be mapped as a rough plane, and the dorsal-ventral axis seems to map clearly to the dorsomedial-ventrolateral axis of the olfactory epithelium.  So any glomerulus will show up at a location on the dorsal/ventral axis of the olfactory bulb that corresponds to the location of the stripe on the olfactory epithelium.  (Actually, there are two sections to the olfactory bulb, the "Main olfactory bulb" and the "Accessory olfactory bulb", part of the accessory olfactory system, but this is not really critical to the discussion at hand and will be left out.)

But it's much more complex along the other axis.  There are many different OSN's occupying the same stripe of the olfactory epithelium, and there will be many glomeruli occupying a similar (mapped) stripe within the olfactory bulb.  How do the neurons sort themselvs out so that all of those expressing one OR end up at the same glomerulus?  What Imai, Yamazaki, et al. have demonstrated is that the axons actually sort themselves into their proper order while growing from the epithelium towards the bulb.

They do this using varying gradients of expression of Neuropilin-1, a multi-purpose receptor for several agonists, including "the secreted repulsive ligand Semaphorin-3A (Sema3A)." This ligand is "expressed not only in the target, but also in OSNs.  Single-cell microarray analysis revealed that Nrp1 and Sema3A genes are regulated in a complementary manner by OR-derived cAMP signals".[13]  That means that the more the ligand is expressed, the less the receptor is, and vice versa.  By appropriate responses of the growing axons, the axons can sort themselves into the proper order before ever reaching their target in the olfactory bulb (OB)[19]:
We found that pre-target axon sorting plays an important role in the organization of the topographic map.  Nrp1 and its repulsive ligand Sema3A are both expressed in OSNs and are involved in axon sorting before targeting on the OB.  Within the axon bundles of D-zone OSNs, DII-A axons (Nrp1 low, Sema3A high) are sorted to the central compartment of the bundle, whereas DII-P axons (Nrp1 high, Sema3A low) are sorted to the lateral-peripheral compartment.  This sorting appears to occur, at least in part, by the repulsive interaction between Sema3A and Nrp1.  In addition to the repulsive interactions, Sema3A and Nrp1 signals may induce homophilic adhesion of axons with Nrp1 itself ([ref]) or with other molecules such as L1 ([ref]).  Furthermore, additional guidance receptors such as Plexin-A1 ([ref]) may be involved in the sorting of DII-A and DII-P axons (fig.  S7).  We assume that similar mechanisms are also at work in the sorting of DI and DII axons (Fig.  1B).

Once OSN axons are sorted in the bundle, they need to be oriented along the correct axis before projecting onto a topographic map on the OB.  This probably requires positional cues that are derived from the target or that are found along the pathway between the olfactory epithelium and the OB.  In the Sema3A total knockout, Nrp1-positive DII-P axons spread rather uniformly across diameter of the bundle (Fig.  5B) and consequently mistarget to the anterior region in the OB (
[refs]).  The effect is different in the OSN-specific Sema3A knockout, where DII-P axons at least gravitate toward the lateral region in the bundle (Fig.  5B).  Thus, Sema3A expressed by cells outside of the bundle likely functions as an additional guidance cue to orient the sorted axons along the correct axis for projection onto OB.  In early embryos, but not in postnatal mice, Sema3A is expressed in the anterior OB (Fig.  5A).  Furthermore, Sema3A is found in ensheathing glial cells along the medial side of the axon bundles (Fig.  5A) ([ref]).  Involvement of such intermediate cues has been reported for the thalamocortical projection ([refs]).[13]
What this means is that the growing axons use varying expressions of the same ligands and receptors as their targets to orient and sort themselves into a rough approximation of the distribution of their targets, before the axon bundle ever reaches that target.  In addition, there is evidence that similar varying expression (or at least secretion) of the ligands involved is provided by supporting glial cells.  (Both neurons and glial cells have the ability to localize their secretion of various signaling molecules, as discussed in Nerve Cells and Glial Cells: Redefining the Foundation of Intelligence)

The implications are important.  In a recent review: Development of Continuous and Discrete Neural Maps (by Liqun Luo1 and John G.  Flanagan), which is open access, the differences between discrete neural maps such as found in the olfactory system, and continuous neural maps such as found in the retina and early visual areas of the brain, are discussed in detail.  "Since visual retinotopic and olfactory glomerular maps represent two ends of a continuum that includes many other types of neural map in between, these emerging general principles may be widely applicable to map formation throughout the nervous system."[11] The mechanisms used are very similar, although the precise means by which each OR maps to a specific concentration ratio of ligands and receptors appears to require more research.  (My guess would be that the ORs actually release varying levels of cyclic Adenosine MonoPhosphate (cAMP) a signaling molecule used within the cell for a wide variety of purposes.  Their levels of release in guiding axon growth are probably (IMO) independent of the level of release found when operating as olfactory receptors, presumably a different mode of stimulation is used during developmental nerve growth.)

What these facts demonstrate is that the axon tracts linking any two parts of the brain, can rearrange themselves from the source mapping to the target mapping.  In the case of the olfactory epithelium, the "mapping" on the anterior/posterior axis appears to be random,[13] for other systems, where it isn't actually random, such mapping can be treated as though it was.

Technically, only one of the two dimensions involved here is remapped, with the dorsomedial-ventrolateral axis of the olfactory epithelium mapping directly (ie without the need for remapping) to the dorsal/ventral axis of the olfactory bulb.  So we can't use this as actual proof that brain regions can remap more than one dimension.  However, if a mechanism like this can be developed once, it can be developed more times, and it's completely plausible that several dimensions of an n-dimensional space could be remapped between communicating brain regions.  This is especially important in the neocortex, where the kind of complex and abstract n-dimensional transformations these functions support could be critical to making intelligence as we know it work.

I've discussed these ideas in Concepts, Cognition, and Anthropomorphism; this remapping process represents a critical enabling function for this kind of operation.  The fact that it shows up in the olfactory system, arguably older than the neocortex, suggests that the development of this capability, or at least certain critical refinements of it, may have been a sine qua non for the development of the neocortex.  Of course, until research into the presence (or absence) of such remapping is done in lizards, turtles, and amphibians, we can't actually know that the entire mechanism wasn't inherited from an earlier ancestor.  Indeed, it may have been present in the earliest jawed fishes.  Still, the appearance and expansion of the neocortex is significant, and until the needed research has been done, it might be best to tentatively assume that some improvements in neural remapping took place just prior to the development of the neocortex.

As for the nuclei, it may well be that these structures are primitive, in the sense that they don't require such remapping, or at least didn't in early vertebrates.  Perhaps the default structure for early nuclei was for each incoming axon to arborize over the entire nucleus, picking and choosing its target cells entirely on the basis of local interactions.  But once the remapping capability had been developed, it seems very likely it would have been reused for tracts targeting those nuclei where it would have been useful.  Thus, we can't assume that nuclei in the mammalian brain don't involve such remapping processes.


Imai, T., Yamazaki, T., Kobayakawa, R., Kobayakawa, K., Abe, T., Suzuki, M., & Sakano, H. (2009). Pre-Target Axon Sorting Establishes the Neural Map Topography Science, 325 (5940), 585-590 DOI: 10.1126/science.1173596

Links:  Only a few of these are actually called out in the text. I've only included the link called out in this leader.  Use the "back" key if you came by clicking a footnote. 

1.  Synaptic organization of the substantia gelatinosa glomeruli in the spinal trigeminal nucleus of the adult cat paywall

2.  From Pheromones to Behavior paywall

3.  Evolutionary Convergence of Higher Brain Centers Spanning the Protostome-Deuterostome Boundary paywall

4.  Lungfish evolution and development paywall

5.  Forebrain evolution in bony fishes paywall

6.  Dendritic neurotransmitter release and its modulation in accessory olfactory bulb circuits

7.  Localization and Targeting of Voltage-Gated Ion Channels in Mammalian Central Neurons

8.  Primary innervation of the avian and mammalian cochlear nucleus

9.  Origin and function of olfactory bulb interneuron diversity paywall

10.  Distribution and phenotypes of unipolar brush cells in relation to the granule cell system of the rat cochlear nucleus

11.  Development of Continuous and Discrete Neural Maps

12.  Contributions of Theoretical Modeling to the Understanding of Neural Map Development

13.  Pre-Target Axon Sorting Establishes the Neural Map Topography paywall

14.  Requirement for Slit-1 and Robo-2 in Zonal Segregation of Olfactory Sensory Neuron Axons in the Main Olfactory Bulb

15.  Odorant Receptor–Derived cAMP Signals Direct Axonal Targeting free registration required

16.  Roles of odorant receptors in projecting axons in the mouse olfactory system paywall

17.  Tenascin-C Is an Inhibitory Boundary Molecule in the Developing Olfactory Bulb paywall

18.  Axons find their way in the snow paywall

19.  Odorant receptors at the growth cone are coupled to localized cAMP and Ca2+ increases

20.  Neural map specification by gradients paywall

21.  Innate versus learned odour processing in the mouse olfactory bulb paywall

22.  Odor maps in the olfactory cortex

23.  Neurobiology: Odorant receptors make scents paywall

24.  Brain Maps.org

25.  Cholinergic Modulation of Dopaminergic Neurons in the Mouse Olfactory Bulb


Read more!

Monday, July 20, 2009

Scientia Pro Publica #8 Is Up...


Here.


In honor of that, and because after last week's four big posts, I'm going to spend today on research (for future posts), there won't be a big one today.

A question for my readers: Saturday's post got a lot more positive response than any previous, and it was also more pointed towards explaining current understanding than my usual Kuhnian revolutionary efforts. Of course, I always try to provide an explanation of what I'm talking about, but that one was the first that really just pointed at summarizing current research, rather than focusing on places where, IMO, current research has gone astray (with, always, the exception(s) of the paper(s) I'm reviewing). Is this what readers want? Or rather, do you (readers) prefer posts that simply summarize current knowledge rather than pointing out major opportunities for paradigm-breaking research?

I promise to read and consider all your comments.

AK Read more!

Saturday, July 18, 2009

The Nature of the Neocortex

ResearchBlogging.org
The neocortex is a mammalian invention, not present in birds, reptiles, or any other vertebrates.  It's associated with the increases in intelligence seen in mammals since the end of the Cretaceous, especially in primates, and more especially in humans.  While there are dozens (probably hundreds) of discussions of the neocortex available on the Web, I haven't been able to find one that meets my needs (for linking to in detailed discussions), so I'm going to produce my own, in the process discussing a recent paper which reflects on it.

The neocortex develops from a part of the developing neural tube called the telencephalic pallium.[17] This is the part of the telencephalon that is towards the back (dorsal) and upper side (dorso-lateral), while the part towards the middle of the body (medial) develops into the hippocampus, including the dentate gyrus and some other parts of the brain associated with memory (especially spacial memory) and navigation.  The bottom (ventral) part of the telencephalon develops into the basal nuclei, which "are associated with a variety of functions:  motor control, cognition, emotions, and learning. [Wiki]" (The telencephalon is split into two parts, one on each side, a feature not visible in Figure 1.)


Figure 1: Parts of the neural tube.  (From Wiki)


We'll come back to the neural tube, but for the moment let's take a look at the structure of the neocortex, by comparison with other structures: ... those that develop from the medial and ventro-lateral part of the pallium, and those in reptiles such as turtles and lizards (crocodilians are too closely related to dinosaurs and birds, and will not be considered) that have been shown to be almost certainly homologous to the neocortex: the dorsal and dorso-lateral cortex.  These latter structures develop from the same part of the pallium in these reptiles as the neocortex does in mammals, and they share many similar connections, so it's worthwhile drawing parallels.

Most sites discussing the neocortex will tell you that it has six layers rather than the three found in these other structures, and that the cells mature from the outside in rather than the opposite.  Many will also tell you that incoming axons arrive from the bottom rather than the top: that is from the direction of the inside of the neural tube rather than the outside.  All these facts are generally true, although some details are often left out and the language is often obscured by the use of various anatomical terms.  Let's go over it in detail.

The first difference has to do with the direction of maturity, the fact that cells mature from the outside in.  Neurons in this part of the neural tube are created by cell divisions in the very inner part of the neural tube, called the ventricular zone.[8] From there, they migrate radially, towards the outer part of the tube (called the pial surface).  In turtles and lizards, these cells begin by settling in the outer part of what will become the dorsal cortex, and later cells settle inwards of them, closer to the center of the nerual tube.  This is what is meant by outside-in maturation, since once they settle, these cells begin to mature.

What most sites discussing the neocortex don't mention is that in the mammalian hippocampus (except for the dentate gyrus) the first cells settle on the inside, closest to the middle of the neural tube, and later cells settle farther out.[8] This is exactly what they do in the developing neocortex,[25] which means that this change is not limited to the neocortex, but is somewhat more general to the mammalian pallium.  It's a good guess that it came first, and it allows for a greater thickness of cortex with interconnections, even without the other changes, as is shown by the structure of the hippocampus.

The next change is the six-layered structure, which arises in the upper dorsal pallium and the dorsal part of the lateral pallium.  This structure probably derives from the more primitive three-layered structure found in turtles, lizards, and the mammalian hippocampus, although the latter has evolved a much thicker outer layer and a characteristic "double-C pattern" with the dentate gyrus curved around the hippocampal gyrus.  The three-layered structure in general is called the "allocortex": this word specifically stands for the parts of the "cerebral cortex" with a three-layered structure, although it's often used for other areas with the same cortical structure.  (The "cerebral cortex" technically refers to the entire cortical area formed from the pallium, but is often instead mistakenly identified with the neocortex.)

We need to start by describing the three-layered structure, then, before we can compare it with the six-layered.  The three layers are like a sandwich, with areas of mostly neurites (axons, dendrites, synapses, and glial cells) making up the bread, while the filling is densely filled with neural cell bodies (somas).  Most of the neural connections come from the outside (the side away from the center of the primitive neural tube), while in this area most of the axons leaving do so out the bottom (the side towards the center of the neural tube).  This provides for a simple "pass-through" system, in which the nerve cells process the incoming information and produce an output which goes to another brain region.

The disadvantage of this system is that the incoming axons are growing along the top of this layer, and trying to make synaptic connections with any cells they encounter.[8] Since most of these cells don't want any specific connection, most of these attempts are refused, which constitutes a major waste of resources.  Which leads us to the third difference, which is that many incoming axons from other parts of the brain come from below in mammals, in more evolved mammals, such as primates and carnivores, virtually all.  We'll discuss this shortly.

Before we do so, we need to consider the layers of the neocortex, which are very different from the allocortex.  The layers of the neocortex are usually numbered I through VI (usually using Roman numerals, although many websites use Arabic).  Layer I is almost completely free of neuron somas, being mostly made up of neuropil, along with blood vessels and other support structures.  Layers II and III have many neuron somas, a good mix of pyramidal cells (see below) and interneurons, the latter usually making local connections with their axons as well as their dendrites.  Layer IV is composed of a mix of stellate cells, which like interneurons make local connections, in the sense that they typically don't extend their axons out of the area they reside, but they extend much farther than interneurons, and they tend to be exitory rather than inhibitory (see below).  Layers V and VI contain mostly pyramidal cells, although with some interneurons, and the lower part of layer VI often contains a large proportion of neurites, especially axon branches.

In the allocortex, the majority of the interconnections are in the upper layer, although the lower layer (the one closest to the middle of the neural tube) has lateral extensions of outgoing axons, which make some connections, probably rising into or through the middle layer.  In the neocortex, the bottom layer, called layer VI, roughly corresponds to this layer, consisting mostly of lateral branches of outgoing axons, which then make connections with other neurons (or glial cells).  The middle layer of the allocortex has often been compared to layers V and the upper part of layer VI of the neocortex, because the cells (with somas) there usually extend their axons to other parts of the brain, as do most of those in the allocortex.[25]

Very few cells of the allocortex (at least in turtles and lizards) make connections to other areas of the allocortex; they mostly talk to other regions of the brain.  Thus, areas II and III of the neocortex, most of whose pyramidal cells send their axons to other parts of the neocortex,[25] can reliably be considered new in mammals.  That leaves areas I and IV, either of which might be compared to the outer layer of the allocortex, although there are differences in both cases.  Axons coming from other regions of the brain usually terminate in layer IV of the neocortex, especially those coming from below, which would make this area comparable to the outer layer of the allocortex.  Axons coming from other areas of the neocortex usually terminate in layer I, which would suggest that it's new.  However, axons that crawl along the outside of the neocortex, most of which come from lower parts of the brain, probably interact with layer I in the same way that similar axons in the allocortex interact with its outer layer, which would imply some comparability there as well.  It's well to remember that these comparisons are merely tools, artifacts of our need to use analogy to understand what's going on.  Evolution is hardly constrained to fit within the categories we make for our convenience.

Before we consider the various connections into and out of the neocortex, let's take a look at the early evolution of the neural tube.  This structure is inherited by vertebrates from their chordate ancestors, indeed recent research shows that the chordates themselves almost certainly inherited it from the earlier common ancestor of the echinoderms, hemichordates, and chordates.[24] I have already suggested that concentration of nerves into a cord was primarily dependent on the availability of a circulatory system that could deliver enough oxygen to power their energy-dependent activity, a development that could have ramped up via the cold temperatures of the "snowball earth" conditions long before the Cambrian.

In chordates and their ancestors this oxygen was essential both to the neuropil, the system of nerve somas, neurites, and glial cells that performed calculations, and the axons which carried the results to other locations within the neuropil.  However, in vertebrates we find Myelin, which insulates the axons and both increases the speed of impulses by perhaps an order of magnitude (or even more, depending on its thickness), and substantially reduces the energy requirements.  This means that the primary requirement for energy was to the neuropil, the "grey matter", while the mass of axons, the "white matter" required much less.

In the original neural tube the neuropil was on the inside, while the axons were on the outside.  This structure is almost certainly primitive, since it's carried over into the retina, where the reversed structure of the neural tube is expressed, and the nerves carrying information from light-sensitive cells actually travel over the surface of those cells (gathering and passing behind the retinal surface in the "blind spot").  In the spinal cord, it was developed into the standard structure of gray matter on the inside and white on the outside, which is very expandable, since most of the axons are traveling in a forward/backward (anterior/posterior) direction, and they are simply pushed farther apart (rather than lengthened) by expansion.  Similarly, an expansion of the gray matter simply thickens it, with little impact.

In the front of the neural tube, things became a little more complex.  Most of the primitive spinal cord was originally dedicated to controlling the actions of a body that was basically eel-like, swimming with an undulating movement, perhaps modifying it's motion with movements of the "fin-flaps" along each side of its body.  Even when the "fin-flaps" came to be replaced with dedicated fins at the front and back, this just caused a small specialization of pre-existing bundles of ganglia, without impacting the effectiveness of the basic structure.


Figure 2: Five vesicle stage of embryo.  (From DEVELOPMENT OF THE CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM


But from the beginning, the brain was different.  As you can see from figure 2, the di-encephalon has a pair of extrusions, which actually develop into the retinas.  The olfactory system, OTOH, develops from the very front of the telencephalon.  This puts the rest of the telencephalon between the optical system and the olfactory system.  What does that mean?

For the earliest vertebrates (or chordates), swimming involved an undulatory movement that caused both the eyes and the nostrils to weave through the water.  In order to identify whatever objects were seen in the water, their path in the visual system had to be integrated with the knowledge of the body's movement (coming from parts of the brain further back) to provide their location relative to the animal's actual path through the water.  With chemicals diffusing through the water, the situation was more complex.  Each object was emitting various chemicals that the olfactory system could sense, which diffused away from it subject to local currents and variations, until after a certain time it impacted the path of the nostrils (usually located at the very front of the animal) as they wove through the water.  Thus the integration of olfactory cues with observed objects was a very complex problem.

In an earlier discussion I mentioned that even the earliest "swimming sponges" would have found a highly beneficial (speaking selectively) use for integrative intelligence, and the same holds true here.  We can't estimate the intelligence of these animals, or this part of their brain, by the number of axons going into or coming out of it, because it might not take many axons to carry the information needed for the calculation, relative to the complexity of the calculation itself.  But this would have made the region of the brain that later became the neocortex essential to the survival and prosperity of these animals, and when the necessary number of neurons and connecting axons grew, evolution provided the answer with the changes we observe in mammals.

If we fast-forward to the development of the earliest mammals, we find animals that used the three-layered allocortex for this process.  At this time, the areas of the dorsal pallium primarily received input from other regions of the brain, especially those that would become the thalamus, and sent their output to other layers, also often (other parts of) the thalamus.  Presumably, this part of the brain performed calculations that were, in effect, straight transformations: integrating and massaging incoming information to provide answer(s) that could be sent on for further use.

I've mentioned that in the allocortex inputs primarily arrived at the outer layer.  Cells in the middle (and lower) layer had to make connections to them, which they did by extending a large dendrite, called the "apical dendrite", to the surface.  What makes them pyramidal in shape (which gives them their name) is that they also extend smaller dendrites in other, lateral, directions, to receive inputs from other cells in their own layer.  This tends to control the shape of the cell, which looks like a pyramid because each of these large dendrites tends to create a "corner" on the cell.  The axon, with its axon hillock, tends to be much smaller, and doesn't really affect the shape of the cell.  Pyramidal cells are the primary type of cell that send axons out of cortical area to other parts of the brain.

The other primary type of cell in these cell-rich layers are interneurons, which are usually inhibitory cells: unlike pyramidal cells (and stellate cells) they use a neurotransmitter (GABA) that tends to cause the target nerve cell not to fire action potentials rather than making it fire as excitatory cells do.  Interneurons tend to have smaller arbors for both their dendrites and axons, although they often enough couple together via electrical (gap) junctions so that a single action potential can spread over quite a distance.  They also usually migrate tangentially from other parts of the developing brain.[25]

In mammals, as well as in dinosaurs and birds, the need for more complete integration of the various calculations, as well as more sophisticated time-dependent analysis, resulted in many further connections between various areas of the future neocortex.  In the ancestors of dinosaurs, this led to the evolution of the wulst, a structure that has sometimes been compared to the neocortex, but has convincingly been shown to have developed independently.[4] [17] In mammals, the neocortex evolved.

The early interconnections between cortical regions, in reptilian ancestors, went via the thalamus.  However, to create a new intercortical connection via the thalamus it's necessary to create a new population of thalamic nerve cells, as well as processes to guide axons from these new cells to the target area of the cortex.  Of course, a new population of pyramidal cells in the cortex is also necessary, which will sample the calculations going on in the neuropil and send the output via their axons to the appropriate spot.  It's also necessary for guidance processes to evolve so that those axons can find their way to where their output is needed.  But if the connection is directly cortical-to-cortical, these are all that are needed: nothing involving the thalamus is required.

The development of new cell types, with their new connections, depends critically on the six-layered structure of the neocortex.  In this regard, I want to mention a recent paper, Cerebral cortex development: From progenitors patterning to neocortical size during evolution (by Alessandra Pierani and Marion Wassef), which unfortunately is behind a paywall.  This paper surveys current knowledge of how pyramidal cell formation is regulated during the development of the neocortex.  A key point is the specification of different subtypes destined for different layers:
The distinct laminar subtypes of neocortical neurons are born in a tightly regulated 'inside-out' sequence.  The neurons destined to the deep layers are produced first followed by neurons fated to populate successively more superficial layers.  Lineage tracing of single radial glia progenitors indicated that, at early stages, radial glia progenitors can produce successively the full repertoire of the major layer-specific neuronal types both in vivo and in vitro.  Transplantation and cell culture experiments have, however, shown that the repertoire of the radial glia progenitors becomes progressively restricted ([refs]).  The group of McConnell has shown that early cortical progenitors at the stage when they normally form layer VI neurons are multipotent and can generate later-born neurons of upper layer II/III, if exposed through transplantation to signals from a late cortical environment ([ref]).  In contrast, later progenitors at the stage when they normally give rise to layer II/III neurons fail to produce deep layer neuronal types when transplanted to an early environment ([refs]).
This means that a complex interaction of transcription factors, and feedback loops among them, progressively tightens the ability of these progenitor cells to differentiate, limiting them to the current stage and later stages.

There have been some exceptions discovered to this pattern in rodents, which might complicate things, they are still under investigation.

There are also tight structures of transcription factors and loops among them that regulate the proliferation of early progenitor cells, controlling the ultimate area of each part of the neocortex.  Pierani and Wassef also discuss the means by which the various parts of the neural tube are sectioned into regions such as the neocortex, and how the areas within it come to be defined.  Gradients of various signalling molecules are built up, so the the ratio of these different molecules at any point is unique, after which a system of cross-repression divides the developing neural tube into specific regions, with gradients of signaling molecules within these regions which presumably allow incoming neurons to find their way to their specific target spot within the region involved.

Precisely how the new layers of the cortex, layers II and III, first arose can only be guessed at (at this point).  It seems likely that the inside-out progression, and the tightly regulated system of distinct laminar subtypes described by Pierani and Wassef, evolved first, laying the groundwork for layers II and III.  Once these layers were present, a new cell population could arise via mutation that targeted another cortical region, a far more likely (or less unlikely) event than depending on a thalamic relay.  We can envision that the progressive evolution of the mammalian neocortex proceeded from this point.

We can see, then, that the neocortex, with its more sophisticated structure, allowed a substantial increase in the interconnectivity of the various regions of calculating neuropil, which in turn permitted the massive expansion of the brains, and intelligence, of the evolving mammals.


Alessandra Pierani, & Marion Wassef (2009). Cerebral cortex development: From progenitors patterning to neocortical size during evolution Development, Growth and Differentiation, 51 (3), 325-342 DOI: 10.1111/j.1440-169X.2009.01095.x

Links: (I've included only the link called out in this leader.) Not all of these are called out in the text, and too many are behind a paywall. Use the back key if you came via a footnote.

1.  The evolution of the neocortex in mammals: how is phenotypic diversity generated? paywall

2.  Genetic and epigenetic contributions to the cortical phenotype in mammals

3.  Similarity and Diversity in Visual Cortex: Is There a Unifying Theory of Cortical Computation?

4.  Do birds possess homologues of mammalian primary visual, somatosensory and motor cortices? paywall

5.  The contribution of spike threshold to the dichotomy of cortical simple and complex cells paywall

6.  Laminar processing in the visual cortical column

7.  Neuronal circuits of the neocortex

8.  The early differentiation of the neocortex: a hypothesis on neocortical evolution

9.  Cortical mechanisms of action selection: the affordance competition hypothesis

10.  Area Patterning of the Mammalian Cortex

11.  Hagfish embryology with reference to the evolution of the neural crest paywall

12.  Cyclostome embryology and early evolutionary history of vertebrates

13.  Migratory neural crest-like cells form body pigmentation in a urochordate embryo paywall?

14.  Brain and Behavior (IPHY 3730), University of Colorado at Boulder not peer-reviewed, but a good overview

15.  Brain segmentation and forebrain development in amniotes paywall

16.  Vertebrate head development: Segmentation, novelties, and homology paywall


17.  Thoughts on the development, structure and evolution of the mammalian and avian telencephalic pallium

18.  The emergence and evolution of mammalian neocortex paywall

19.  The functions of the preplate in development and evolution of the neocortex and hippocampus paywall

20.  Cortical Excitatory Neurons and Glia, But Not GABAergic Neurons, Are Produced in the Emx1-Expressing Lineage

21.  Postnatal development of the telencephalon of the tammar wallaby (Macropus eugenii). An accessible model of neocortical differentiation paywall

22.  Development of the olfactory system in a wallaby (Macropus eugenii) paywall

23.  The Medial Pallium

24.  Centralization of the Deuterostome Nervous System Predates Chordates paywall

25.  Cerebral cortex development: From progenitors patterning to neocortical size during evolution paywall


Read more!

Friday, July 17, 2009

Greening the Earth

ResearchBlogging.org

It's an interesting question, when did photosynthetic life first invade dry land, and what type was it? The tradition is that green plants first invaded the land in the Ordovician or Silurian, if not later, sometime after 500 MYA,[7] well after the Cambrian, when we first see fossils of animals developing in the ocean (there are actually some from earlier, but those may not be animals, and we know little about them). However, there are various lines of evidence that there was already extensive land-based photosynthesis going on a good deal earlier,[3] [4] including a very recent paper:[2] The late Precambrian greening of the Earth (by L. Paul Knauth and Martin J. Kennedy, unfortunately behind a paywall), which examined the correspondence of ratios of carbon isotopes and oxygen isotopes in precambrian deposits, specifically from areas influenced by runoff from continents:
Here we compile all published oxygen and carbon isotope data for Neoproterozoic marine carbonates, and consider them in terms of processes known to alter the isotopic composition during transformation of the initial precipitate into limestone/dolostone. We show that the combined oxygen and carbon isotope systematics are identical to those of well-understood Phanerozoic examples that lithified in coastal pore fluids, receiving a large groundwater influx of photosynthetic carbon from terrestrial phytomass. Rather than being perturbations to the carbon cycle, widely reported decreases in 13C/12C in Neoproterozoic carbonates are more easily interpreted in the same way as is done for Phanerozoic examples. This influx of terrestrial carbon is not apparent in carbonates older than ~850 Myr, so we infer an explosion of photosynthesizing communities on late Precambrian land surfaces. As a result, biotically enhanced weathering generated carbon-bearing soils on a large scale and their detrital sedimentation sequestered carbon. This facilitated a rise in O2 necessary for the expansion of multicellular life.
This analysis basically plotted the isotope ratios from thousands of observations on a two-dimensional axis, and observed that those from after about 850MYA fell into the same groups whether they were after the beginning of the Cambrian or before. This leads to the very plausible conclusion that photosynthesizers had colonized the land and were producing large amounts of carbon-rich detritus that was then oxidized and deposited.

This has some interesting implications: ...
The contrasting isotope data between 850 Myr ago and the Neoproterozoic suggest that the terrestrial expansion of photosynthesizing communities preceded the significant climate perturbations of the late Precambrian glaciations, and was followed by a rise of O2 ([ref]) and a secular change in terrestrial sediment composition. The onset of significant biotically enhanced terrestrial weathering would have increased the flux of lithophile nutrient elements and clay minerals to continental margins. This would have increased production and burial preservation of organic C towards modern values and consequently facilitated the stepwise rise in atmospheric O2 necessary to support multicellularity. The terrestrial expansion of an extensive, simple land biota indicated by the isotope data may thus have been a critical step in the transition from the Precambrian to the Phanerozoic world.
The biggest problem with this is the lack of fossils identifiable as from plants, although the "squishier" plants leave few fossils.

There is one very important feature of plants that allowed them to colonize the land: the invention of mixtures of lignin and cellulose that protects them against the "soft" ultraviolet radiation (UV) that makes it through the ozone layer. This mixture, in turn, depends on a synthesis pathway that begins with an enzyme called Phenylalanine Ammonia Lyase (PAL), "which catalyses the first and essential step of the general phenylpropanoid pathway, leading from phenylalanine to p-Coumaric acid and p-Coumaroyl-CoA, the entry points of the flavonoids and lignin routes."[8]

Another very recent paper, A horizontal gene transfer at the origin of phenylpropanoid metabolism: a key adaptation of plants to land (by Giovanni Emiliani, Marco Fondi, Renato Fani, and Simonetta Gribaldo) reports an intriguing discovery: that the gene for this enzyme was almost certainly acquired via horizontal gene transfer from a soil bacterium, or perhaps from a fungus that had in turn acquired it from a soil bacterium. What they did was to examine the phylogenetic tree of "160 representative sequences" from various species, discovering that all the genes in plants and fungi are descended from a single ancestor related to those of one bacterial lineage. This gene "is homologous to histidine ammonia lyase (HAL), which is involved in the catabolism of histidine and is widespread in prokaryotes and eukaryotes [refs]. It has been proposed that "PAL developed from HAL when fungi and plants diverged from the other kingdoms" [ref]. However, the current view of eukaryotic evolution based on phylogenetic analyses indicates that fungi and plants do not share an exclusive ancestor [refs]. In fact, Fungi are more related to Animals than to land plants. Moreover, land plants belong to the phylum Plantae, which also includes Glaucocystophytes, red algae, and green algae [refs]."


Figure 1: Phylogenetic tree of HAL/PAL gene. Click on image to see original with caption. (From Ref 8 Figure 2)


This, combined with the observations of Knauth et al., brings us to an interesting suggestion: is it possible that, before green plants invaded the land, it was covered with lichens? Lichens, even today, often grow in areas that are heavily exposed to sunlight (UV) but lack the soil necessary for plant roots (and their symbiotic association with certain fungi). Absent plants, they may well have been able to colonize just about any area with sufficient rainfall to provide the water they needed. Lichens are known to invade rock for nutrients,[6] and even cyanobacteria, one of the groups of algae that for symbiotic relationships with fungi to create lichens can chemically erode rocks.[5] The possibility that there was a coating of lichens over most of the Earth's surface as long as 850MYA is quite intriguing.

An obvious question is: what, if anything, ate these lichens? Here I want to hark back to a suggestion I made a while back, regarding the origin of multi-celled animals, and probably other forms of life:
Could it be that the common ancestor of fungi and animals was actually multinucleate, an amoeba-like creature with lots of nuclei, a flexible shape, and a feeding pattern based on engulfing its food?

Such a creature would be well positioned to evolve into both fungi and metazoans, with the latter branch having lots of collared flagelli. The question is, why evolve multiple cells? The answer could well be an explosive adaptive radiation of invasive, intracellular predators. Such an explosion would explain the sudden acquisition of multicellularity by many lineages.
It isn't just animals and fungi that would be so descended, and it's quite possible that a variety of multinucleate amoeboids were present in these early times that fed on the early lichens I've proposed. (Indeed, there are many such today. These may well have lived in small, shaded tunnels during the day (when solar UV may well have threatened them), and come out at night to feed on the upper levels of the lichens. The lichens themselves may have used some form of lignin (or dyes depending on PAL for synthesis) to protect themselves from the sun, although another possibility is that they shed their upper levels as they were damaged, regrowing from cells located deeper, where they were protected from UV. Or it could have been a combination of both.

The possibility that there was a full-blown ecosystem present on the land this long before the Cambrian offers exciting possibilities in understanding the earliest evolution of the animals (in the ocean), as it would have provided large quantities of detritus for food, along with the oxygen needed to take advantage of it. Especially important is that it this would have been true during the two proposed eras of "snowball earth" or "Slushball Earth", when glaciation extended quite far towards the equator: large areas of the earth's coastline would have experienced freezing temperatures along with intense sunlight.

This is important because water close to the freezing point can actually contain enough oxygen to function as blood in an animal that isn't too active, unlike warmer water. This means that animals during those periods might have invented sophisticated circulatory systems, carrying oxygen for all their needs, without the need for cells containing haemoglobin or some other compound specialized for carrying larger amounts of oxygen. By the time the glacial ages were over, presumably some lineages (at least of chordates) had already developed blood cells containing haemoglobin, thus kicking off the chordate/vertebrate adaptive explosion.


Knauth, L., & Kennedy, M. (2009). The late Precambrian greening of the Earth Nature DOI: 10.1038/nature08213

Emiliani, G., Fondi, M., Fani, R., & Gribaldo, S. (2009). A horizontal gene transfer at the origin of phenylpropanoid metabolism: a key adaptation of plants to land Biology Direct, 4 (1) DOI: 10.1186/1745-6150-4-7

Links: (I've included only those links called out in this leader.)These are almost all behind paywalls, unfortunately. I wish they weren't, but...

1.  Plant-driven fungal weathering: Early stages of mineral alteration at the nanometer scale paywall


2.  The late Precambrian greening of the Earth paywall

3.  Late Precambrian Oxygenation; Inception of the Clay Mineral Factory free registration required

4.  Molecular Evidence for the Early Colonization of Land by Fungi and Plants free registration required

5.  Effect of cyanobacterial growth on biotite surfaces under laboratory nutrient-limited conditions paywall

6.  Mineralogical transformation of bioweathered granitic biotite, studied by HRTEM; evidence for a new pathway in lichen activity paywall


7.  The early development of terrestrial ecosystems

8.  A horizontal gene transfer at the origin of phenylpropanoid metabolism: a key adaptation of plants to land


Read more!

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Concepts, Cognition, and Anthropomorphism

ResearchBlogging.org
Ever since Plato, western philosophers have looked at words, and the objects they represent, as a sort of fixed ideal:  the word "couch", for instance, represents an object, or rather one of a class of objects.  Lately, in the last few centuries, scientists and/or philosophers have recognized that the same word might represent different, but widely overlapping, classes under different circumstances (contexts), a fact that often leads to confusion, sometimes deliberate.  All of this tends to focus attention on the relationship between words and symbols, strengthening the notion that humans are the only "Symbolic Species", since the evidence is overwhelming that no other species (with a few possible cetacion exceptions) uses language in anything like the way we do. 

But is that true?  How closely are symbols, and the concepts they represent, tied to language and the use of words as symbols?  For that matter, what is a symbol, in terms of cognition, or the mechanics of our brains? 

Before we explore these questions, let's back up and take a look at the context:  the paradigm within which we are asking these questions, understanding what they mean, and judging the answers. 

It began with Plato, as mentioned above.  From his work we get the concept of the Platonic Ideal:  the perfect representation, the archetype, behind a concept represented by a word.  As he explained it, we are chained in a cave as it were, looking at the back wall, able to see only shadows cast by the ultimate, ideal, reality cast by the light of "Truth", because we are unable to turn and look out the entrance. 

This paradigm was pretty much universal by Hellenistic times (a few centuries after Plato) in the west, and also, I suspect, in the east where it had spread via Persion/Greek influences to India, and from there via Chan/Zen Buddhism (and possibly other schools) across North Asia to China.  (My suspician is partly founded on the fact that Zen Koans seem well designed to break the tyranny of words/concepts as absolutes, forcing the seeker to recognize that these things are only limited tools, like a set of shelves which are fine for holding small solid objects, but limited for very large objects and useless for liquids.) 

The reality, as recent research is showing, is that our brains typically identify words heuristically:  we learn of a number of items that belong to a class represented by a word, our minds (often subconsciously) identify common features or characteristics of these items, and we tentatively identify new members of the class based on those same shared features/characteristics. ...

Backing up again to Plato, we can see that there's no reason that such classes require an "ideal" at all:  they are just groupings of items that are all similar enough to justify attaching a word, a symbol, to the class.  A concrete example may be helpful:  consider the word "couch".  This may be loosely defined as a bench with a back and armrests (at least in modern usage), long/wide enough for at least two people to sit comfortably.  Can we define a Platonically ideal couch?  Not without context.  For instance, to Victorians such a couch would have had a reasonably vertical back and stiff cushions, helping to support people who were expected to sit up with good posture while socially interacting.  But for modern laid-back music lovers, the ideal couch will be much more relaxed, allowing occupants to lean back and totally relax while losing themselves in musical reproductions not available even live to Victorians. 

Thus, the ideal, singular to Plato, splits into many depending on context, observer, and time.  The problem is that our thought patterns, our paradigms, are constrained by over two thousand years of Plato's influence, and they often interfere with efforts to understand how language, symbols, and concepts work. 

It's certain that the human brain has a mechanism for representing words:  my best guess is that they're normally represented (in at least one area of the brain) as abbreviated "shorthands" for the sequence of tongue, lip, mouth, throat, and diaphragm movements that go into pronouncing them.  But is this true of concepts?  Did recent human ancestors invent the concept, or the symbol that stands for it?  Are even our closest relatives lacking this feature? 

I think not.  We know that many primates possess "mirror neurons", pyramidal cells in parts of the neocortex that tend to fire in the same groups when the animal is performing (or preparing to perform) some action and when it's observing some other animal performing that action.  I would say that actions of this sort represent concepts, and that the processes around the firing of these "mirror neurons" represent neurological symbols (or the use of them).  At a sufficiently abstract level, there's no real difference between a specific pattern of lines on a piece of paper (or clay) and a specific pattern of neurons in the neocortex (or a specific pattern of sounds). 

Before we go farther, we need to examine how the mammalian neocortex operates.  I'm going to use Francis Crick's Astonishing Hypothesis as a base, although it's highly simplistic and probably wrong in some details.  As he does, I'm going to focus on the V1 area in the visual cortex, which receives input from the retina (via the lateral geniculate nucleus: a part of the thalamus), performs a complex transformation on it, and sends the results on to further areas of the brain. 

The large majority of axons coming from the retina carry a single type of message:  each neuron is watching a specific location in the retina, looking for a specific type of spot against an opposite background:  some look for big spots, some for small.  Some for dark spots (against a light background), some for light.  some for red spots (against a presumably green background), some for blue, green, purple, etc.  Now all of these things these different neurons are looking for can be mapped onto an n-dimensional space:  in this case with n probably equal to five:  two dimensions for the location within the retinal field, one for size, one for color, and one for light/dark.  The light/dark axis may be discrete rather than continuous; it may even be two-valued.  The color axis also may be somewhat more complex than my simple description makes it sound:  there are some complications regarding the distribution of cone types within the retina that time and space don't permit discussing.  These points don't affect the basic picture:  the visual field of the retina can be mapped as an n-dimensional space of "spots" with each neuron sampling a specific location in that space and responding accordingly. 

Of course, most of the visual field isn't made up of spots (although in the world of the earliest chordates it may well have been:  our evolutionary history is often built into our design in ways we wouldn't suspect).  What each neuron in the retinal population I'm discussing does is look to see how much the visual input resembles the type of spot it's looking for, and the more it does, the larger its firing rate (the faster it fires action potentials).  Notice, then, that what we have here is a continuous function over a continuous space (disregarding complications involving a discrete light/dark axis) varying continuously over time, but sampled at discrete points in space and time.  Each neuron occupies a specific point in the n-space and samples that one point (although since it's actually examining the vicinity looking for a spot, one close to its location would generate a partial signal).  Each neuron intermittently sends a signal with its instantaneous firing rate, thus the closer it is to seeing what it's looking for, the more frequently its signal is being sampled. 

What does the V1 area do with this information?  The major populations of pyramidal cells look for bars:  wide bars, thin bars, vertical bars, horizontal bars, dark bars, light bars, red, blue, green, purple, etc.  And everything in-between.  The information brought from the retina (relayed via the lateral geniculate nucleus) is integrated and messaged by the cortical neuropil and the stellate cells of layer IV, eventually allowing the pyramidal cells to sample an n-dimensional space of bars and send their signal accordingly.  (Actually, the situation is more complex because these cells are also looking for time-dependent patterns as well, but if they can support the more complex situation, they can certainly support the simpler one.) 

Are we beginning to see a pattern here?  Nerve cells in at least two parts of the brain can, in effect, occupy a discrete location in some n-dimensional space, sample a scalar signal at that location, and output the results to their axons, whence it's carried to other parts of the brain.  (The vertebrate retina is part of the brain developmentally:  it starts out as part of the neural tube and is then drawn away into the eye structure.  It's not part of the neocortex, however, the retina had differentiated and specialized a long time before the ancestors of mammals invented the neocortex.[1]) 

We don't need, here, to go into how this process is achieved:  it's enough to know it can be done.  And what one area of the brain can do, so can any other:  whatever the mechanism, it's almost certainly reusable.  (Note, however, that just because this mechanism is available to every part of the brain doesn't mean every part of the brain uses it.  OTOH when we're looking for a mechanism to explain some observation, it is an obvious candidate.) 

Let's get back to our "concepts" within the brain represented by specific groups of neurons (such as "mirror neurons") firing when a specific "concept" is called to mind in an animal, either by seeing some other animal performing an action or by performing, or preparing to perform, that action.  Based on the description above, it's a good guess that those neurons occupy a specific location in some n-dimensional "concept space" that corresponds to the specific act involved.  Of course, since at this level of consciousness humans, and probably other primates, normally pay attention to only one general subject at a time, it may be that each individual concept is represented by a unique pattern:  sort of like an ideogram but in n dimensions rather than just two. 


Figure 1:  Cursive hieroglyphs (a type of ideogram) from the Papyrus of Ani, an example of the Egyptian Book of the Dead.  (From Wiki)


At this point I want to discuss some very recent research:  Mirror Neurons Differentially Encode the Peripersonal and Extrapersonal Space of Monkeys ( by Vittorio Caggiano, Leonardo Fogassi, Giacomo Rizzolatti, Peter Thier, Antonino Casile), which is unfortunately behind a paywall, but let me blockquote the abstract:[3]
Actions performed by others may have different relevance for the observer, and thus lead to different behavioral responses, depending on the regions of space in which they are executed.  We found that in rhesus monkeys, the premotor cortex neurons activated by both the execution and the observation of motor acts (mirror neurons) are differentially modulated by the location in space of the observed motor acts relative to the monkey, with about half of them preferring either the monkey's peripersonal or extrapersonal space.  A portion of these spatially selective mirror neurons encode space according to a metric representation, whereas other neurons encode space in operational terms, changing their properties according to the possibility that the monkey will interact with the object.  These results suggest that a set of mirror neurons encodes the observed motor acts not only for action understanding, but also to analyze such acts in terms of features that are relevant to generating appropriate behaviors.
Unlike many abstracts, this one is pretty easy to understand, and its implications are extremely relevant to the subject here.  The "mirror neurons" under examination are associated with motor activity, and may well be associated with a system of representing "concepts" with shorthands of motor sequences. 

I mentioned above that in my view the representation for words in the human brain is some sort of "shorthand" for the sequence of muscle actions involved in pronouncing it; similarly it makes sense that in monkeys, apes, and other primates with "mirror neurons" the representation in at least one area of the brain for "concepts" involving actions is a similar shorthand for the muscle actions involved.  Or rather, the shorthand in primates came first, and the process was adapted for use with language by adding specific tongue, lip, mouth, throat, and diaphragm movements to a system already adapted for arm, leg, hand, and foot movements. 

In trying to understand how "concepts" are represented in the brain, we need to consider how they're used.  As Caggiano et al. point out, the relevance of an action undertaken by another depends (in kind as well as quantity) on the distance of that other, and it makes sense that the specific "concept" activated in the brain is slightly different depending on that distance.  Rather than trying to separate these different reactions into completely separate concepts, perhaps we should think of this as more like adverbs modifying a verb:  the same action stimulates the same concept, but the distance, both absolute and operational, stimulates distinct modifying adverbs.  Of course, we must also keep in mind that this research looked at only one area of the brain, and that one being associated with motor activity, specifically the planning and execution of such activity.

We need to keep in mind that the brain is made up of many areas, all talking to one another:  in rhesus monkeys there are 52 areas just on each side of the neocortex, this may also be the number for humans, although the detailed research needed to prove it hasn't been done yet for ethical reasons.  There may be, probably are, more than one area involved in expressing these "concepts", and each area probably uses a different system of representation.  Exactly how these areas express their concepts, and the precise relationships among expressions in different areas, is a subject for future research.  However there are some things we can be fairly sure of from what we know already. 

For one thing, the brain appears to operate on a very associational basis:  if one area is stimulated to "fire" a certain concept it will likely stimulate other areas to fire the same concept.  Some of these areas may act to relate concepts to one another, others may act to related observations of other animals to various concepts that classify their actions, yet others may act to relate concepts for proposed actions to specific conditions such as food lying on the ground nearby or hanging from a nearby branch, yet others may serve to react to various concepts with responses from memory regarding past incidents where similar actions took place in similar circumstances.  The relationship among these various areas may then allow a decision regarding whether, and how, to undertake the action this concept represents. 

Again quoting from Caggiano et al., this time from the conclusion:[3]
Our results suggest a cognitive role for mirror neurons as a system that not only encodes the meaning of observed actions but also contributes to choosing appropriate behavioral responses to those actions.  In particular, a stimulating (although admittedly speculative) interpretation of our results is that mirror neurons not only may represent a neuronal substrate for understanding "what others are doing," but also may contribute toward selecting "how I might interact with them."
Notice that in all this I've essentially expanded the use of "concepts" to all primates possessing "mirror neurons".  This makes sense, since if the firing of a certain pattern of neurons in even one area of the brain represents an attentional focus on one particular idea, such as a class of actions, it makes a valid symbol, and symbols can be reasonably considered to represent concepts.  Language doesn't come into it.  Or rather, language came into it very late in the game, when one lineage of apes came to represent a well-established system of symbolism within the brain with something that could be easily communicated to other members of the local group. 

Thus we can see that while language is very likely (but not certain) to be a human invention, the use of symbols, and the concepts they represent, is probably much older:  language certainly added a dimension or more to the utility and effectiveness of symbols and concepts, but the original system was in place at least tens, and possibly hundreds, of millions of years earlier. 


Caggiano, V., Fogassi, L., Rizzolatti, G., Thier, P., & Casile, A. (2009). Mirror Neurons Differentially Encode the Peripersonal and Extrapersonal Space of Monkeys Science, 324 (5925), 403-406 DOI: 10.1126/science.1166818

Links: Not all of these have been called out in the text.  Use the back key if you came via clicking a footnote. 

1.  The Early Differentiation of the Neocortex:  a Hypothesis on Neocortical Evolution

2.  Genetic and epigenetic contributions to the cortical phenotype in mammals

3.  Mirror Neurons Differentially Encode the Peripersonal and Extrapersonal Space of Monkeys paywall
Read more!

Monday, July 13, 2009

Encephalon 73 is Up

With three of my better (IMO) posts, along with a great line-up. Each post is accompanied by a video searched out by the editor, Sandra Kiume. See it here. Read more!