Monday, August 17, 2009

Diagonal Postures & The Descent from Human to Ape

Homeotics, Cladistics and the Triple Emergence of Closed Hand Gaits in Descendants of an Upright Ancestor of the Apes


ResearchBlogging.orgGuest Post by Aaron Filler, MD, PhD, FRCS

If an upright bipedal ancestor evolved first, why would three of its descendant lineages abandon orthograde posture and restore quadrupedal gaits to their repertoire?

Firstly, we don't have to have an answer as to why it happened if that is indeed what happened. If it occurred, then it occurred whether or not we have proposed and accepted a post-hoc adaptationist explanation for it.

This week in PNAS, a paper from Tracy Kivell and Daniel Schmitt,[9] reports on differences between the functional anatomy of knuckle walking of gorillas as distinct from the basis in chimpanzees, strongly supporting the idea that these are two similar but independently evolved locomotor complexes. They go on to argue that humans therefore did not evolve from a knuckle walking ancestor.

These authors have focused on significant differences in the carpal bones that underlie the two forms of knuckle walking. There is a long and heated history of publications in this area (see the Upright Ape[6] for a more detailed discussion of the knuckle walking controversy). Kivell and Schmitt[9] add significant new information about the mechanics and anatomy of knuckle walking as it relates to the very different carpal bone structure in the two lineages. This work does greatly strengthen the argument that there is no proven basis for making these two adaptations into a single shared change that should have been present in the group ancestral to hominins.

On an adaptive basis, one of the arguments most strongly advanced for the preference of closed hand gaits in various hominoids is that the tendons are shortened to result in a passive "hook" of the hand when the arm joints and wrist are extended. This is for the purpose of efficient suspension from branches during hand hanging and locomotion.[14] However, in the light of the Humanian model I have advocated,[6],[7] there would be a multi-million year history of locomotion without hand/arm use and a behavioral reliance on use of the hands for carrying crude tools and small food objects. Closed hand gaits allow hominoids to hold objects in their hands as they locomote - it is easy enough for an adaptationist to explain the adaptive benefit of being able to carry during locomotion when you are in competition with an upright bipedal hominoid. Classical Darwinists often miss this point because of the focus on competition with other species members, but Stephen Jay Gould has pointed out the seemingly obvious importance of competition above the systematic level of the species.[8] This is all about what upright bipeds and knuckle-walkers do on the ground when they compete for resources - and fight with each other - in overlapping territories.

The homeotic mutationist position that I have advocated (The Upright Ape,[6] Homeotic Evolution of the Mammals[5]) tackles the question from the perspective of genetic drive and adaptationist fine tuning. The starting point is the demonstration that the Moroto vertebra demonstrates a truly remarkable transformation of the vertebrate body plan.[5] In most mammals and indeed in most vertebrates - the main dorso-ventral body plane division is placed ventral to the neuraxis, but in a "hominiform" clade that includes hominins, some extant apes, Morotopithecus, Pierolapithecus, Oreopithecus, Orrorin and Sahelanthropus the body plane is shifted to a position dorsal to the neuraxis in the lumbar region.





A number of anatomical transformations in serial homology accompany this change and all of them appear at 21.6 million years ago in Morotopithecus. These include a "box-like" cross section of the lumbar transverse process as opposed to the more standard mammalian flat element and this appears to be evidence of bipedal rather than bimanual orthogrady - e.g. standing and walking rather than arm swinging. The anatomical basis of upright posture in modern humans is very clearly due to this transformation and it is fully present in Morotopithecus. Because of this, I have argued that this feature is the basis of a hominiform clade that separated from the proconsuliform hominoids very soon after the first emergence of hominoids in the early Miocene.



Sudden major transformations of this type are the province of mutationist[17] rather than adaptationist evolutionary progression and are best suited to changes in the major morphogenetic genes such as the homeotic genes. The prime irrefutable example that challenges traditional evolutionists who refuse to understand the implications of modern morphogenetics is the origin of the vertebrates from the invertebrates. Invertebrates have their digestive tract dorsal to their neuraxis, while vertebrates have the neuraxis dorsal to their gut. Invertebrates develop the mouth from the blastopore, but vertebrates develop the anus from the blastopore. To get from the invertebrate body plan to the vertebrate body plan, you have to flip dorsal for ventral and anterior for posterior. An adaptationist argues that there were selective adaptive pressures that gradually turned the proto-vertebrates a few degrees at a time over millions of years. The morphogentic mutationist realizes that this is completely ridiculous and that - as the genes show - the readout gradients in the embryo got flipped.

Vertebrates with the dorsal neuraxis and "aboral" blastopore emerged in abrupt single generation transformations that led to a revolutionary new body plan. In Morotopithecus bishopi we see a similar morphogenetic revolution and the result is the proto-human that does not use its hand or arms to locomote. This most likely occurred in a single generation. A quadrupedal proconsulid-like ape mother and a bipedal orthograde child that was our clade founder once its descendants were isolated by a chromosomal speciation event.

I point out in the Upright Ape[6] that every fossil hominoid species in the hominiform group for which we have post-cranial fossil evidence appears to be an upright adapted form and that there is no evidence yet of any knuckle walkers. The accepted position has been that humans evolved from knuckle walkers around 5-6 million years ago even though there has never been any evidence for this at all. The contrary position that I have advocated is supported by all the evidence from all of the five separate genera of hominiform hominoids known with post-cranial evidence from before the chimp-human split, distributed across time from the 21 to 5 mya, yet my position is the one that has been considered radical.

The general dictates of science are that more credence should be given to a theory with a variety of elements of supporting evidence and less credence to a theory that fits expectations but for which evidence has not yet been found. There are numerous objections to the Humanian Model - a blog I wrote on this subject on Anthropology.net drew nearly 20,000 views and attracted scores of comments making up a good mix of hostile and supportive reactions. However this suggestion has had a very significant impact (Science Daily, blog on afarensis, blog on scientific blogging, MSNBC) because of the strength of the evidence. It was also well received when presented at the 2008 meeting of the American Association of Physical Anthropology[7] and was addressed specifically in presentations others - who reached conclusions consistent with the components of the Humanian Model.[15] David Pilbeam - past Chairman of Biological Anthropology at Harvard - wrote the foreword for the Upright Ape.[6]

Although I first laid out the case in 1986 in Axial Character Seriation in Mammals (republished in 2007),[3] the publication of my 2007 books and papers coincided with the publication of work by Thorpe[19] and Crompton[2] arguing for a upright climbing antecedent for our terrestrial bipedal lineage. There have been three more new hominoid species reported since mid-2007,[18],[12],[10] but none of these finds has included significant new post-cranial fossils. However, analysis of spinal evolution by Rosenman and Lovejoy[15],[16] is consistent with the Humanian model, an analysis of hand bones from Hispanopithecus laeitanus has demonstrated no sign of knuckle walking,[1] and now the new report from Kivell and Schmitt[9] on knuckle walking adds yet more weight to the non-Troglodytian models (no knuckle walking for the human ancestor).



Various studies show the inefficiency of chimpanzee bipedal walking and argue that only by a series of modifications could we arrive at the efficiency of the bipedalism of extant humans.[13] However, this assumes that the common ancestor of chimpanzees and humans walked bipedally the way a modern chimpanzee does when a more correct scenario is probably that the common ancestor walked more as we do - and that its ancestors already had a 15 million year career of minor adaptations improving the effectiveness of bipedal gait.

In the Upright Ape,[6] as well as in the Homeotic Evolution of Mammals[5] and a paper on later Emergence and Optimization of Upright Posture for bipedalism,[4] I update the original (1986)[3] hypothesis by pointing out that the best way to view the locomotor specializations of modern orangs, chimps and gorillas is as examples of "diagonograde" posture. The basic hominiform spine - due to a homeotic mutation - is defective in that it loses the basic mechanical structure that supports the horizontal or pronograde spine in most mammals. This is what occurred in Morotopithecus and has never been restored. In most hominiforms, we retain a very flexible lumbar spine with five or six lumbar vertebrae. However in the orang, the chimp and the gorilla, the lumbar spine is dramatically shortened - to as few as three lumbar vertebrae and independently evolved bony stops that limit hyperextension of the non-orthograde spine appear - each quite independent and different in those three lineages.

Russell Tuttle[20],[21] showed that Orangutans do not knuckle walk - they fist walk. Owen J. Lewis[11] showed that there was no clear shared anatomical basis for knuckle walking in the hominoid wrist (see Upright Ape for numerous references). Kivell and Schmitt[9] have now showed that there are indeed two very distinct functional anatomical patterns for knuckle walking that distinguish chimps and gorillas.

So...if a series of hominiform hominoids share the long flexible lumbar spine that can't function usefully in pronograde or diagonograde postures, if all of these genera of hominiforms demonstrate anatomical features for support upon pelvis below rather than by suspension, and if the orangs, chimps and gorillas have independently evolved short stiff lumbar spines and closed fist diagonograde gaits, then what stands against a Humanian model of human evolution?[6],[7] Certainly there is a mountain of writing, publications, textbooks, theory and belief against it - but there is no actual scientific evidence to support anything other than an upright ancestor for the extant apes and humans.

I have further tried to look closely at what we mean by the word human (OUP blog: Redefining the Word "Human" - Do Some Apes Have Human Ancestors?). As I detail in the Upright Ape, we have Sherwood Washburn to thank for our anthropological definition of the word human and it is basically a hominoid that is bipedal and upright. Clearly, when we look at that century in the early Pliocene that immediately followed the speciation event that sealed the chimp-human split we would now have "humans." These humans would have a brain size no different from a chimp, tool use no different from a chimp, and communication no different from a chimp. The assumption has been that the common ancestor of chimps and humans would look like a chimp - an obvious "ape" - however, what if the common ancestor looked pretty much like the early humans. What if it is the human lineage that retains the primitive traditional hominiform body plan that has been around since the time of Morotopithecus?




I think we all know what we mean by "early human" - they have our basic body form but have smaller ape-like brains, shorter legs, a bigger set of jaws and teeth, and a big toe that spreads out further from the other toes than ours does now. Since the Oxford English Dictionary is probably the best forum for this question, it is on the OUP blog that I placed my piece on redefining the word "human".

From the point of view of cladistics, we really can't use the term "apes" anyhow since this does not form a monophyletic group. From that perspective, we would have to include humans as apes. In fact when you look at the actual sequence of events among the hominiforms and extant apes, "humans" came first, but then the cladists would have us calling the extant apes "humans" and that is not what anyone means. Hominiforms is a good cladistic term for the humans and extant apes. The word human - including early humans and proto-humans - is a good term under Ernst Mayr's view of biological naming in systematics (see discussion in the Upright Ape). We can also say Hominiforms of human body plan (HHBP). All of these issues arise because systematic diversification (speciation) does not necessarily coincide with morphological diversification - some primitive body plans are more effective than the modifications that appear in some descendants.

This is the specific point that Ernst Mayr attacked most specifically in challenging the Hennigian paradigm. In cladistics, whenever a new species arises, we have two daughter species and we say that the parent species is now extinct. Mayr felt that the typical situation was that you had a large slowly evolving population that occasionally emits a speciated branch with a subset of the genetic variability of the parent species. He felt it was biological nonsense to say that a species was now extinct if the genetic makeup of the parent species and the major daughter species were identical.[22] In our situation - we would have a large parent species of human form out of which a small group becomes isolated that leads to the chimpanzees. We agree that the post-split group that is bipedal is now "human" but the pre-split group (from the century before the speciation event) is effectively identical. That pre-split group should be called "human" as well and then we have a human group ancestral to an extant ape lineage - at least in that situation.

One thing that all the naming and systematics logic does not affect is the apparent fact that the immediate ancestors of the all the extant clades of apes & humans had the appearance of modern humans in their body plan.

So we have hominoids that share a modified Y-5 molar and which includes the pronconsuliforms and the hominiforms. The hominiforms are basically upright and of human body form - or humanoid. From the early Miocene to the present, there has always been a lineage of upright primarily bipedal hominiform hominoids whose body plan is of human aspect. In essence these are creatures that don't use their hands and arms for locomotion.

Across time, various groups branch off that are more suited to ecologies and locomotor arenas where humans don't compete as effectively - that is because it has always been difficult for nonhuman-like hominoids to compete against those with human form. The proconsuliforms long since went extinct and the others have not succeeded sufficiently to leave any post-cranial fossils. Meanwhile, the upright bipedal hominiforms with a body plan of human aspect have left an increasingly abundant fossil record that spans 21 million years. They were not stooping forward and they may have been seen occasionally in trees (see my video of Siamang bipedalism and human brachiation: Hominiform Progression on You Tube, in high res on Vuze or as an iTunes podcast). At any point during this time span, if you were to encounter a hominoid it would most likely have been an upright bipedal species that when seen from a distance looked...well... human.

Kivell, T., & Schmitt, D. (2009). Independent evolution of knuckle-walking in African apes shows that humans did not evolve from a knuckle-walking ancestor Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0901280106

References:

1. Almécija S, Alba DM, Moya-Sola S, Köhler M. Orang-like manual adaptations in the fossil hominoid Hispanopithecus laietanus: first steps towards great ape suspensory behaviors. ProcRoySocB 274:2375-2384 (2007) Open Access

2. Crompton RH, Vereecke EE, Thorpe SKS. Locomotion and posture from the common hominoid ancestor to fully modern hominins, with special reference to the last common panin/hominin ancestor. J Anat 212(4):501-543 (2008) Open Access

3. Filler AG. Axial Character Seriation in Mammals: An Historical and Morphological Exploration of the Origin, Development, Use, and Current Collapse of the Homology Paradigm. Brown Walker Press, Boca Raton, FL, (2007).

4. Filler AG. The emergence and optimization of upright posture among hominiform hominoids and the evolutionary pathophysiology of back pain. Neurosurgical Focus 23(1):E4 (2007).

5. Filler AG. Homeotic evolution in the Mammalia: Diversification of therian axial seriation and the morphogenetic basis of human origins. PLoS ONE 10(e1019) (2007). Open Access

6. Filler AG. The Upright Ape: A New Origin of the Species New Page Books, New Jersey, July (2007).

7. Filler AG. A Humanian Model of Human Evolution: Evidence that habitual upright bipedality is a synapomorphy that defines a hominiform clade of hominoids including humans and all extant apes. American Association of Physical Anthropology, 77th Annual Meeting, Columbus, Ohio April 10, 2008. AJPA 135 (S46): p.96 (2008)

8. Gould SJ. The Structure of Evolutionary Theory. Cambridge, Mass., Belknap Press of Harvard University Press (2002).

9. Kivell TL, Schmitt D. Independent evolution of knuckle-walking in African apes shows that humans did not evolve from a knuckle-walking ancestor. PNAS (2009). paywall

10. Kunimatsu Y et al. A new Late Miocene great ape form Kenya and its implications for the origins of African great apes and humans. PNAS (104) 19220-19225 (2007). Open Access

11. Lewis OJ. Functional Morphology of the Evolving Hand and Foot. Oxford/New York, Clarendon Press ;Oxford University Press. (1989).

12. Pickford M, Coppens Y, Senut B, Morales J, Braga J. Late Miocene hominoid from Niger. C.R. Palevol 8:413-325 (2009). paywall

13. Pontzer H, Raichlen DA, Sockol MD. The metabolic cost of walking in humans, chimpanzees, and early hominins. J Hum Evol 56:43-54(2009).

14. Preuschoft H. Mechanisms for the acquisition of habitual bipedality: are there biomechanical reasons for the acquisition of upright bipedal posture? J Anat 204(5): 363-84. (2004). Open Access

15. Rosenman BA, Lovejoy CO. Developmental anatomy of the hominoid lumbar transverse process: a comparative anatomical framework for examining lumbar natural history in early hominids. American Association of Physical Anthropology, 77th Annual Meeting, Columbus, Ohio April 12, 2008. AJPA 135 (S46): p.183 (2008).

16. Rosenman BA, Lovejoy CO. Relative lumbosacral transverse process length in extant hominoids and australopithecines. American Association of Physical Anthropology, 78th Annual Meeting, Chicago, IL April 3, 2009. AJPA 138 (S48): p.183 (2009).

17. Stoltzfus A. Mutationism and the dual causation of evolutionary change. Evol Dev 8: 304–317. (2006). paywall

18. Suwa G, et al. A new species of great ape from the late Miocene epoch in Ethiopia. Nature 448: 921-924 (2007). paywall

19. Thorpe SKS, Holder RL, Crompton RH. Origin of human bipedalism as an adaptation for locomotion on flexible branches. Science 316: 1328-1331 (2007). requires free registration

20. Tuttle RH . Knuckle-walking and knuckle-walkers: A commentary on some recent perspectives on hominoid evolution. Primate Functional Morphology and Evolution. R. Tuttle. Chicago, Mouton/Aldine: 203-209. (1975).

21. Tuttle RH. Knuckle-walking and the problem of human origins. Science 166(908): 953-61 (1969). paywall

22. Wheeler Q, Meier R. Species Concepts and Phylogenetic Theory : A Debate. New York, Columbia University Press. (2000). Read more!

Encephalon 74 is up

Here.

Lot of good articles there. You'll probably want to check it out. Read more!

Thursday, August 13, 2009

A Big Boost for a Revolutionary Theory

ResearchBlogging.org
One of my more favorite reads was Aaron Filler's Upright Ape:  A New Origin of the Species[3], shortly after it was published.  The suggestion(s) regarding human evolution were attractive and revolutionary, while the discussions of homeotic mutations and their mechanisms (based upon peer-reviewed work[4]) were enlightening and form part of the foundation of my own approach to understanding how mutation, development, and Darwinian selection work together (a subject I haven't blogged much about although it underlies much of my writing here).

Filler's primary suggestion is that the main stem lineage of the Great Apes has been walking upright since shortly after it diverged from the ancestors of the ancestors of the gibbons and siamangs due to a homeotic mutation that modified the spine to give it the potential to support an upright stance for long periods, something the gibbons and siamangs lack.  (Although they can and do walk upright, both in the canopy and on the ground.) One of the implications of this theory is that the common ancestor of humans, gorillas, chimpanzees, and bonobos walked upright, and that knuckle-walking behavior evolved independently in the lineage leading to gorillas from that leading to chimpanzees and bonobos.


Figure 1:  Example of the detailed anatomical discussion of the proposed homeotic mutation that lead to the human/great ape backbone structure.  Click on image to see illustration and caption at the book's website.  (From Reference 3, figure 9-5.)


Now, in the advance online Early Edition of PNAS, we find Independent evolution of knuckle-walking in African apes shows that humans did not evolve from a knuckle-walking ancestor[2] (by Tracy L.  Kivell and Daniel Schmitt), unfortunately behind a paywall, that describes research thoroughly undermining the notion that humans evolved from a knuckle-walking ancestor.  Let's look at the research first:  ...

What Kivell and Schmitt did was examine the "features most commonly thought to reflect knucklewalking behavior in the African ape wrist", in terms of their occurrence and development in many primates, and especially gorillas as well as chimpanzees and bonobos.  They found "(i) that most gorillas lack key features that have been assumed to be critical for limiting extension of the wrist during knuckle-walking ([refs]), and (ii) these features are found in monkeys that use a variety of different hand postures and substrates."

Assuming that such features are necessary (or highly desirable) for knuckle-walking, we should find them emphasized in gorillas, and at earlier ages, since gorillas are larger, thus putting more stress on the bones of their hands during knuckle-walking, and normally start earlier during development.  Instead: 
In addition, the ontogenetic analysis shows that the features of the scaphoid that are assumed to be essential for knuckle-walking ([refs]) are not only inconsistently developed in Gorilla, but, when present, do not appear relatively earlier in development in gorillas (Table 2).  Therefore, using the traditional functional interpretation of these features ([ref]), it would appear that the Gorilla radiocarpal joint may be actually less, rather than more, stable in extension throughout ontogeny compared to Pan.
The mention of stability during extension of the radiocarpal joint (bending back the wrist) leads to the next important feature of this report:  the proposal that the method of knuckle-walking used by gorillas is different from that of chimpanzees and bonobos. 
We propose that Gorilla uses a relative ‘‘columnar’’ forelimb posture during knuckle-walking in which the hand and wrist joints are aligned in a relatively straight, neutral posture compared to the more extended postures adopted by Pan (Fig.  3).  Animals using a relatively columnar wrist and hand posture would have carpal joints that are in line with the hand and forearm, similar to limb joint position in large graviportal animals such as elephants ([ref]).  Supporting loads directly over more vertically-oriented forelimb joints during support phase explains the absence of posited bony adaptations to bending loads in gorillas and also permits more mobility at the joint ([ref]).  By contrast, Pan, which exhibit extended wrist postures (Fig.  3), will experience higher bending loads.  Thus Pan carpal bones have relatively prominent osteological features that have traditionally, but mistakenly, been interpreted simply as features associated with knuckle-walking in general rather than with a specific posture.  The notion that Pan and Gorilla use different wrist postures is consistent with the morphometric data presented here.  Although this hypothesis has yet to be explored in detail with videographic data, this idea is further supported by previous research showing that Gorilla exhibits increased wrist mobility compared to Pan ([ref]), a more hyperextended elbow joint ([ref]) and relatively equal length of rays 2 through 4, which creates a larger, more stable area over which to disperse axial loads ([ref]).
Imagine the difference between doing push-ups on your fists and on a steel bar you've got your hand wrapped around with your wrist bent back.  This is sort of what the difference is, but only sort of.  Unfortunately, their "figure 3" is behind a paywall, but the important takeaway is that there is a difference in mechanism, the details of that difference, while important, aren't necessary to the wider implications.

Kivell and Schmitt have provided very strong support for the idea that knuckle-walking works differently, is used differently, and probably evolved independently in these two lineages.  A less technically oriented discussion (than the paper) is provided by Science Daily[1], I'm not going to try to replicate their work.  (afarensis, FCD is not really convinced, I've discussed Filler's theory in comments on his (old) blog, and I've expanded and modified some of my arguments there in this post.)

Support for the Upright Ape

Instead, I'm going to discuss how this new research relates to the "Upright Ape" hypothesis.  One key hypothesis here is that the homeotic mutation to the spine "pre-adapted" it to support the upper body when standing, walking, or running upright.  I won't go into the details, but with this adaptation in place, we need to ask precisely why any possessor would go in for knuckle-walking.  The answer is that the requirements of brachiation (swinging from the arms) include suppressing a twisting movement between the hips and the shoulders, a need that grows greater with greater size (mass).  An ancestral "Great Ape" weighing no more than a typical gibbon might have found this movement easy to suppress, but a larger ape that depended on brachiation would have been under some selective pressure to suppress this movement.

(Another possibility, IMO, is that the lumbar structure of gibbons has actually become adapted to use the springy structures of the lumbar transverse process (LTP) to provide energy storage from/to this twising moment, which in Great apes must be suppressed by muscular action at the cost of energy.  AFAIK no research has been done into this possibility.  I'll mention that the springy structures involved are used in most mammals to counter the drop of the belly, allowing it to be suspended during walking and storing energy during running/leaping, while in Great apes it tends to counter the forward droop of the upper body while standing upright (because it has been moved dorsally of the center of flexion (bending) of the backbone by the homeotic mutation).  For more detail, I must refer you to the book,[3] I just don't have the expertise, and haven't done the detailed research, to attempt it.  Thus I must also leave my suggestion regarding the gibbons as a possibility, until I find research (if any) into the details of how these structures work during active brachiation.)

Filler makes the case that the long hip structures and functionally short lumbar structures in African Great Apes represent adaptations to this selective pressure, and then goes on to argue that there are enough differences that this adaptation was probably made independently in chimpanzees/bonobos vs. gorillas.  He also makes a persuasive case that this adaptation is responsible for making it much harder for African apes to walk upright efficiently, because they are forced to twist their body with, rather than counter to, their hips.  This, then, would explain the parallel adoption of knuckle-walking by the two lineages during or after their divergence from each other and also from that leading to humans, which appear to have happened in one event (with gorillas diverging earlier from a lineage that later split to create those leading to chimps/bonobos on the one hand and humans on the other, although IMO a more complex triple split with a sustained period of reduced gene flow is more consistent with the evidence).  The common ancestor was either small, made little use of brachiation, or both.  After the split, both lineages developed into comparatively large-bodied brachiators, later becoming increasingly terrestrial and now dependent on knuckle-walking where the common ancestor would have used upright walking somewhat similar to that of gibbons and siamangs.

A suggestion (by Thorpe, Holder, and Crompton) that bipedalism developed among arboreal apes as "an Adaptation for Locomotion on Flexible Branches"[7] was countered by a comment (by Begun, Richmond, and Strait) referring to the evidence of shared features indicative of knuckle-walking and appealing to parsimony as demonstrating its use in the common ancestor of humans and African apes.[9] With this paper,[2] we see the argument of the Begun team dissolve:  There is no longer any strong evidence of knuckle-walking in the common ancestor, or any of the central lineage(s) of the great apes.

The Thorpe/Crompton team hasn't stood still, a more recent review examines a great deal of detail regarding the mechanics of locomotion, especially with respect to foot-ground contact and the movement of the center of gravity (COG), in support of an arboreal origin for bipedalism.  They deal with the knuckle-walking hypothesis thus:[5] 
To our knowledge, Gebo is the only supporter of the knuckle-walking hypothesis to have offered a functional argument linking knuckle-walking and the origins of modern human bipedality, but as we have shown, his argument, which is restricted to foot function, is poorly supported by the data.  No explanation appears to have been offered of how the characteristic flexed hindlimb postures of knuckle-walking gait could have been pre-adaptive for the extended hindlimb postures of modern human walking, or indeed how the transformation could have occurred.  Further, the knuckle-walking hypothesis requires that orthogrady evolved twice:  from pronograde simians to the orthograde crown hominoids – and then following an adoption of terrestrial knuckle-walking by the common African ape ancestor to orthograde bipedality in hominins.  We prefer the alternative, that knuckle-walking evolved evolved independently in gorillines and panins, as the ontogeny of phalangeal and metacarpal scaling ([ref]) and of other 'knuckle-walking features' ([ref]) is different in panins and gorillines, suggesting that knuckle-walking evolved more than once among the African apes.
Kivell and Schmitt have certainly provided great support for this preference.  However, there are some problems with this latest (AFAIK) volley.

Although they mention Filler's work with homeotic mutations,[4] Crompton et al. do not (as far as I can tell) take note of the implications of lumbar stiffening as an adaptation for brachiation in larger-bodied apes, although it seems fully consistent with their model.  Apes that spent most of their time clambering around in an upright position (with little brachiation) might well have had no need for such lumbar stiffening.  More importantly, Crompton et al. fail to allow for the selective advantage of the springy backbone supporting the upper body.  (In fact, even Filler puts more emphasis on support standing or walking rather than running.)

Crompton et al. actually discuss the use of heel-strike in walking by various apes, and mention the "lack of heel-strike in modern hylobatids",[5] but fail to make the connection to the shock-absorbing, and especially energy-storing capacity, of the springy lumbar structures of Great apes (including humans).  Of course, I don't recall any special emphasis on this in the book, but then the Filler wasn't arguing against the Thorpe/Crompton suggestion of arboreal bipedalism.  Although I can't speak as an expert, it seems to me that the advantages of the Great Ape lumbar structure would primarily apply to ground and very large branches/trunks, where the elastic support for the upper body could cushion the jarring effect of the heel-strike and store at least part of its energy.  Landing on smaller branches with a heel-strike would be less problem, as they could provide the springy support, alternatively too much force could destabilize things, so the heel-strikes used by Great Apes on small branches are probably as careful as those of humans on icy pavement.

Problems with Current Selective Models

What this suggests to me is that the stem lineages of great apes relied much more on terrestrial movement than Crompton et al. suggest.[5] Of course, reliance doesn't necessarily mean frequent use.  One major problem I have with all these studies is their tacit assumption that energy efficiency, or frequent use, represent a good measure of selective advantage.  Apes are social animals, which means that intra-specific competition is extrememly important in selection, both within and between social groups.  The "winners" of these competitions could be expected to have as much as they needed to eat, so energy efficiency would be less important than victory.  Similarly, all such competition is ultimately "life-and-death", at least reproductively, given the reproductive advantages accruing to high-status individuals, so adaptations that reduce the risk of high-risk behavior involved in such competition would likely be selectively advantageous even at the cost of efficiency, and even when the behavior involved is not frequent.

In arguing for an arboreal origin for bipedalism, Crompton et al. state: 
Kingdon (2003) has proposed that in Africa, from the Middle to Late Miocene, fragmentation of closed forest alternated with reclosure and reinvasion of gallery-forest, moist-woodland and rainforest environments, changes also clearly documented by Elton (2008)[13].  Within branches of both the Pan and the Gorilla lineages, the height-range and frequency of vertical climbing locomotion must have increased, suggests Kingdon (2003), to facilitate access to preferred foods in the main and emergent canopy, while permitting travel between trees in broken-canopy woodland on the ground.  Middle Miocene crown hominoids, such as Hispanopithecus (Dryopithecus) laietanus, are of a similar size range to living great apes, although undoubtedly male body weights for living great apes exceed estimated values for the Miocene.  Thorpe et al. (2007a)[7] thus speculate that the gorillines and panins, independently, became increasingly specialized on forelimb power, to sustain safety and effectiveness of increased vertical climbing, and so tended to adopt similar, extended-elbow, flexed-hip-and-knee kinematics when moving on the ground, hindlimb musculature being unable readily to sustain hip and knee extension and hence a bipedal gait.  Hominin ancestors, we speculate, sacrificed continued access to the canopy, and became increasingly ground and small-tree dwellers.  Lacking the increased specializations for vertical climbing, they were able to sustain a bipedal gait – and we may add, inasmuch as they were terrestrial, that they could sacrifice coronal-plane mobility, which also characterizes the orangutan, in favour of more effective parasagittal force-production.
Alternatively, my best interpretation of Filler would suggest that the "gorillines and panins, independently, became increasingly specialized on" brachiation, perhaps not often but in selectively critical circumstances, producing the independent lengthening of the hip and stiffening of the lumbar region adduced by Filler, but making the ancestral bipedalism very inefficient, producing independent adaptations for knuckle-walking.  "Hominin ancestors", pretty much retained the ancestral condition, which would be very Australopithecus-like.  Only with the appearance of the lineage(s) called "Homo habilis" and the transition to a Homo erectus-like form do we find the more sophisticated gaits found in modern humans.

The suggestion that the ancestral "Great Apes" possessed a functional upright bipedalism pretty much identical to that of the Australopithecenes, with all the modern "Great Ape" lineages representing separate offshoots independently adapted for arboreal lifestyles at the expense of the ancestral bipedalism, is generally consistent with both Filler and the Thorpe/Crompton team.  However, the issue of the relationship between heel-strike and the lumbar modifications speaks for a much greater reliance on terrestrial movement than is consistent with the Thorpe/Crompton arboreal explanations.

Although Filler didn't speak to it, I think we should consider the environmental implications:  conditions were not always a closed canopy: 
Mid and late Miocene African catarrhines are associated with a variety of habitats, over time as well as in different places ([refs]).  Early Miocene sites such as Mfwangano Island and Songhor, sampling several catarrhine genera including Proconsul and Rangwapithecus, probably had environments containing evergreen, multi-canopied forest ([refs]).  The early Miocene catarrhines radiated extensively into such arboreal habitats, filling frugivorous, folivorous, above-branch and mixed arboreal/terrestrial niches ([ref]).  The slightly more recent (c. 18 Ma) Hiwegi Formation on Rusinga Island, by contrast, appears to have single-canopied, disturbed woodland, known best from a rich floral assemblage ([ref]).  Unfortunately, it has no directly associated ape fossils although several taxa are known from Rusinga Island deposits of a similar age ([ref]).[13]
Given the widespread lack of fossils, we can't assume that any area lacking fossils lacked some sort of ape population.  Proconsul, according to Filler,[3] did not possess the specialized lumbar structures found in Great Apes, although a very similar species did.  The "evergreen, multi-canopied forest" mentioned by Elton[13] may well have been similar to the primary environments of both African and Asian modern Great Apes, while the "single-canopied, disturbed woodland" is another type of environment entirely.  With broken canopies, and even a single canopy which would not have been completely opaque, there would have been much more undergrowth.  This in turn would have led to much more scrambling and clambering moving over the ground.  The "disturbed" aspect of the woodland suggests considerable downwood, placing all sorts of obstacles to overland transport.  I would suggest that from the earliest expansion of the "Great Apes", that is those possessing the lumbar adaptations adduced by Filler, they specialized in rapid movement through this sort of terrain.


Figure 2:  Example of "disturbance":  damages of storm Kyrill in Wittgenstein, Germany.  (From Wiki.)


In areas with high relief (from erosion), there wouldn't have been a clear boundary between this sort of movement and low arboreal movement through the "single-canopied, disturbed woodland".  Mammals the size of Proconsul spend a lot more energy in vertical movement than horizontal,A1 so an ability to move horizontally, or as close to it as possible, through a variety of micro-landscapes would be adaptive.  So would an ability to run (when necessary, see above) over hard ground and large branches/logs at similar levels.  Unlike the "assisted bipedal walk"[12] that may be the safest way to cross high bridges, bipedal running during necessary high-risk activity would probably have depended on balance.  This is hardly surprising, many primates can be taught to ride a bicycle, a task demanding great balance.


Figure 3:  High relief terrain, from Oregon.  This is badlands, much less wooded than the type of terrain I'm discussing, but it allows you to see the relief because of the lack of vegetation.  Imagine forest over this terrain, with frequent disturbance as in Figure 2.  (From the files of OregonLive.com.)


Given the generally Australopithecus-like fossils being found in Africa, some evidently dating back as early, or earlier, than the best date for the split between the lineages leading to humans vs. chimps/bonobos,[5] [13] even parsimony, unreliable as it is, would suggest that the common ancestor was pretty much Australopithecus-like.

We can extend this argument to orangutans:  given the many apparent similarities shared by humans and orangutans but not by chimps or gorillas, these may well have been inherited from an Australopithecus-like ancestor.  In this case the arboreal (brachiating) adaptations of all three lineages would have been evolved independently, with different suites of ancestral features retained to be shared with humans.

Personally, I find Filler's hypothesis very convincing, more so than either the Knuckle-walking or the arboreal bipedalism explanations.  And this paper provides strong support (although it doesn't say anything against arboreal bipedalism).


Kivell, T., & Schmitt, D. (2009). Independent evolution of knuckle-walking in African apes shows that humans did not evolve from a knuckle-walking ancestor Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0901280106

Appendix: You can use the back key to return to where you were, or click on the quoted text to return to the line with the footnote.

A1.  "Mammals the size of Proconsul spend a lot more energy in vertical movement than horizontal":  This is because the mammalian ratio of basal metabolic rate to weight decreases with weight differently than the energy involved in vertical movement varies with weight, as does the energy involved in movement at all.  I have been unable to find any discussion of this online, and can't even recall where I read it.  I find it hard to believe that this subject has been ignored in discussions of arborial vs. terrestrial movement:  I suspect there's something wrong with my search technique.

Basically, an animal the size of a squirrel spends almost as much energy moving horizontally as vertically, and the difference isn't all that large (for mammals with their high metabolic rate) from standing still.  Both differences increase with increasing body weight (technically, mass).  Obviously, the effect also varies by type of movement.


Links:  I've included only the links called out in this leader.  Not all of these links are called out in the text.  Use the back key if you came via clicking a footnote.

1.  Bipedal Humans Came Down From The Trees, Not Up From The Ground ScienceDaily (Aug. 11, 2009) not peer reviewed


2.  Independent evolution of knuckle-walking in African apes shows that humans did not evolve from a knuckle-walking ancestor paywall

3.  The Upright Ape:  A New Origin of the Species by Aaron G. Filler MD, PhD

4.  Homeotic Evolution in the Mammalia:  Diversification of Therian Axial Seriation and the Morphogenetic Basis of Human Origins open access

5.  Locomotion and posture from the common hominoid ancestor to fully modern hominins, with special reference to the last common panin/hominin ancestor paywall

6.  Orangutan positional behavior and the nature of arboreal locomotion in Hominoidea

7.  Origin of human bipedalism as an adaptation for locomotion on flexible branches free registration required

8.  The Origins of Human Bipedalism paywall

9.  Comment on "Origin of Human Bipedalism As an Adaptation for Locomotion on Flexible Branches" Open Access

10.  Response to Comment on "Origin of Human Bipedalism As an Adaptation for Locomotion on Flexible Branches" Open Access

11.  Locomotor Ecology of Wild Orangutans (Pongo pygmaeus abelii) in the Gunung Leuser Ecosystem, Sumatra, Indonesia:  A Multivariate Analysis Using Log-Linear Modelling paywall

12.  Orangutan Positional Behavior and the Nature of Arboreal Locomotion in Hominoidea

13.  The environmental context of human evolutionary history in Eurasia and Africa Open Access


Read more!

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

In the Google Top 20

While browsing through the detailed reports from Sitemeter, I just made gratifying discovery: one of my posts is currently in the top 20 for a major Google search: The Nature of the Neocortex shows up on page 2 (Results 11 - 20 of about 807,000 for neocortex) of the results page for a search on "Neocortex".

I don't know much about how Google orders its search results, although I've heard that number of links and traffic have something to do with it. And, although I shouldn't say it, perhaps the fact that they advertise on this site has something to do with it. But Google advertizes on a lot of sites, and I'm guessing they get a lot more clicks from sites with less of a focus on nit-picking scientific details.

I don't know how long it will stay on the top 20: perhaps semi-forever, perhaps it will be lower tomorrow. But thanks to all the readers who created and/or followed links to that post. Read more!

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

A New Integrative Theory for Cortical Pyramidal Neurons

ResearchBlogging.org
A discovery reported in last Friday's Science Magazine offers a new unifying principle for how pyramidal cells perform their function in the neocortex, as well as other cortical areas:  Synaptic Integration in Tuft Dendrites of Layer 5 Pyramidal Neurons:  A New Unifying Principle (by Matthew E. Larkum, Thomas Nevian, Maya Sandler, Alon Polsky, and Jackie Schiller), unfortunately behind a paywall.  What this paper does is demonstrate that a type of neural activity called an NMDA spike (see below), already known to occur in the basal branches of the dendrites of pyramidal cells, also occur in the branches in the apical tuft, the arborization that occurs at the top of the apical dendrite, the main dendrite that reaches from the soma (body) up to the top layer (Layer I) where the majority of synaptic connections are made between incoming axons (from other brain regions) and pyramidal cells (which produce outgoing axons to other brain regions).[1] 

As of late 2007, "NMDA spikes have been observed in basal dendrites but not apical dendrites",[4] but now: 
We report the existence of N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) spikes in the fine distal tuft dendrites that otherwise did not support the initiation of calcium spikes.  Both direct measurements and computer simulations showed that NMDA spikes are the dominant mechanism by which distal synaptic input leads to firing of the neuron and provide the substrate for complex parallel processing of top-down input arriving at the tuft.[1]
Before we look at what these NMDA spikes are, let's look briefly at the implications of this discovery:

Integrative Calculations in Pyramidal Neurons


Figure 1:  Structures of selected pyramidal neurons from different cortical areas.  Click here to see full image and original caption.  (From Reference 4, figure 1..)


Figure 2:  Simplified (!) diagram of the calculating modules according to the "New Unifying Principle" in Reference 1.  Each box represents an integrative calculating unit, capable of performing a large variety of calculations with its inputs.  The circles represent input information coming via synapses.  Note that the logical organization here doesn't map exactly to the physical organization of the neuron:  the non-linear voltage responses of the synapses, the locations of the synapses on the local branches, and the non-linear voltage responses of the dendritic membrane of the local branches should all be considered part of the calculation box.  The input, then, consists of the flow of neurotransmitters across the synapse.  The timing of the arrival of the action potential, and any calculations that take place in the pre-synaptic neuron, aren't included in this diagram.  Click on image to see larger version.  (Original.  You may link to, copy, and/or modify this image, as long as you give credit with a link to this post.)


Looking at Figure 2, we can see that there are a number of modules, potentially nested, which perform semi-independent calculations.  They feed their results to modules progressively closer (and ultimately identical) to the soma, which (along with the axon hillock and the first 50-100 microns of the axon) performs the final calculation regarding whether, and when, to fire an action potential.  Prior to this research, the modules in the apical tuft (those feeding the proximate apical dendrite, see also figure 1) were regarded as different in kind from those in the basal branches.[4]  What this research has (tentatively) demonstrated is that the integrating modules called "Fine Dendrite Branches" in Figure 2 appear to act in very similar fashions, although they provide their outputs to different places.[1] 

The outputs of from the tuft branches feed the integrating/calculating module represented by the proximate apical dendrite, which performs a calculation that involves a process called a "calcium spike" (see below), which had been thought to be caused in the tuft branches,[4] but with this research are (tentatively) shown not to be caused in the branches, but only in the proximate apical dendrite.[1]  This permits the "New Unifying Principle": 
The thin distal tuft and basal dendrites of pyramidal neurons, which receive the overwhelming majority of synaptic inputs ([ref]), appear to constitute a class of dendrite in which NMDA spikes are the predominant regenerative events summing synaptic inputs in semi-independent compartments.  The output of each subunit in this class of dendrite is passed on to the major sites of integration at the axon and apical calcium initiation zones, which can all interact via actively propagated signals ([ref]), enabling the interactions between top-down and bottom-up information.[1]
This represents a major change to how pyramidal cells should be viewed, offering different pictures of their modular breakdown and evolution. ... We can reasonably suppose that the evolution of the neocortex involved, among other things, some improvements and refinements to the integrating calculation process of the apical calcium initiation zones in the proximate apical dendrite.  Pyramidal neurons "are abundant in the cerebral cortex of virtually every mammal that has ever been studied, as well as in those of birds, fish and reptiles, but not amphibians."[4]  They are: 
found in most mammalian forebrain structures, including the cerebral cortex, the hippocampus and the amygdala, but not the olfactory bulb, the striatum, the midbrain, the hindbrain or the spinal cord.  Thus, they are found primarily in structures that are associated with advanced cognitive functions[.][4]
We can reasonably suppose that the original version, developed either by early amniotes (and independently by fish), or much earlier in vertebrate evolution (and lost by ancestral amphibians), was only capable of supporting the three-layer cortical structure of reptiles and the allocortex of mammals. 

Currents, Spikes, and Action Potentials

The functioning of a neuron is very complex, with a very large number of interacting "moving parts".  Any effort to simplify the picture to the point that it can be discussed in a blog post will inevitably lose critical details, as well as producing a picture that fails to apply to most types of these cells.  Nevertheless, we can look at a few general processes that are common to most (if not all) neurons.

The first thing we need to consider is the cell membrane, and various differences between the inside and outside.  The two critical differences for our purposes are the voltage across the membrane, and the different concentrations of certain critical ions:  sodium (Na+), calcium (Ca+2), potassium (K+), and chloride (Cl-).  Both the concentration differences and the voltage tend to drive a movement of ions across the membrane, however they can't get through the membrane proper without the help of ion channels, of which every type of neuron is provided with a large number of many types.  In a typical resting state, Na+ is being "pulled" into the cell by both concentration difference and voltage, while K+ is closer to equilibrium, with a smaller "push" outwards because the resting voltage across the membrane isn't quite enough to balance the difference in concentrations.  Ca+2 is being "pulled" inwards even harder than Na+, while Cl- is a special case, in some neuron membranes at rest seeing a slight "pull" inwards, while in others there's a slight "push" outwards.[22] [23] (I won't be covering Cl- in this post, this is a subject for a future post.) Each ion has an equilibrium voltage which will exactly balance the concentration difference.[24]


Figure 3:  Equilibrium Voltages and the Effect of Various Ion Currents on Membrane Potential.  Note that the equilibrium voltages (ENa+, ECa2+, EK+, and ECl-) are actually ranges, depending on the specific ion concentrations inside and out.  This is especially important in the case of Cl-, where variations in concentration can move the equilibrium voltage to either side of the Resting Membrane Potential.  (Based on Reference 24 Figure 2.2, p41.  You may link to, copy, and/or modify this image.)


Now, the actual voltage across the cell membrane will be determined by the relative concentrations of all (charged) ions, along with more transient effects created by various currents.  These currents are caused by the flow of charged ions through ion channels and ion pumps.  Ion pumps tend to run at a (roughly) constant rate, so their currents are roughly constant, balanced by typically small currents through ion channels that are slightly open at the resting voltage.  This balance creates the resting voltage, and can be changed by long-term changes to ion channels that occur e.g. between various states of consciousness.[24]

It's very important to realize that the membrane voltage, and concentration differences across the membrane with their associated equilibrium voltages, can vary between cells, between different parts of the cell, and over time even for the same part of the cell.  A large number of factors go into determining the voltage, and even the concentration differences are subject to a number of interacting controls, not all of them part of the specific cell in question.[14] [24]

Currents, both resting and transitory, are produced and controlled by a large number of ion channels, many of which have very complex and often time-dependent reactions to voltage, ion concentrations (including those that they don't pass, for instance there are two K+ currents, well enough known to be named, that are controlled by the internal Ca+2 concentration:  IC and IAHP, produced and controlled by calcium activated ion channels), and the concentrations of a large variety of messenger molecules and neurotransmitters, both inside and outside the cell.[24]

A spike is a sudden change in voltage caused by a large transitory current of some sort.  The best-known spike is the action potential, which is a regenerative positive-feedback current of sodium and/or calcium produced by voltage-gated channels for these ions.  We need to consider what the word "regenerative" means in this context:  when the voltage across the membrane drops to and past zero at one point on the membrane, it causes the voltage nearby also to drop, which in turn activates voltage-gated channels in these nearby positions, causing the positive feedback process that creates the action potential.  (The voltage-gated channels usually shut after a short time (around a millisecond (ms)), especially the sodium channels that mediate the action potential in the axon, the best known.) This is the "regeneration": one process causes the voltage to drop at a specific point on the membrane, and when it passes a threshold a new, voltage-dependent process regenerates a further voltage drop, amplifying the initial impulse.

There are other types of spikes:  localized non-propagating Na+ and Ca2+ regenerative currents that amplify local voltage changes caused by other currents.  Sodium and Calcium are the principle spiking ions, because of the strong forces pulling them into the cell.  In principle, K+ could also cause a spike, with the voltage change going in the other direction, but this doesn't seem to happen in nature.  However, there are many types of spikes where channels open for both Na+ and K+, going in opposite directions and creating currents opposed to each other, where the much larger driving force on Na+ overwhelms the K+ force, producing a net inwards current.

We need, now, to take a closer look at the voltages involved.  As you can see from figure 3, membrane voltage at any point can be moved by changes to any of the various currents.  When a burst of neurotransmitters from an action potential arrives at a synapse, they will have various effects on the ion channels that are present, causing various currents.  The effect of the currents is to either depolarize or hyperpolarize the membrane, bringing its voltage closer or farther away from the action potential threshold.[24]


Figure 4:  Action Potential Threshold and Directions of Depolarization and Hyperpolarization Relative to Figure 3.  (Based on Reference 24 Figure 2.2, p41.  You may link to, copy, and/or modify this image.)


Now, in an action potential, voltage-gated Na+ and/or Ca2+ channels open when the voltage falls below their threshold, causing a spike where the voltage continues to fall.  Because there is a large number of such channels present throughout the local membrane, the spike at one point drags down the voltage at nearby points, causing the channels there to open.  Thus the spike propagates itself at nearby points on the membrane, and moves away from its initiation point along the axon or back from the soma along the major dendrites, if they possess the right mix of voltage-gated channels. 

Suppose, however, that there's just a large concentration of a certain type of voltage-gated channel at one point.  In this case, the current created by ion channels responding to a burst of neurotransmitters (from an action potential in another neuron) might bring the voltage to the threshold, causing the concentration of channels to open and amplify the original current with a regenerative current of their own.

There is a constant rain of these bursts of neurotransmitters on various synapses at various locations on the dendritic arbor.  Each creates currents, some depolarizing, some hyperpolarizing, and the effects spread from the synapse along the cell membrane.  The original current fades as the neurotransmitters are taken up and their effects pass, meanwhile the voltage at the synapse decays as the charges transferred spread out along the membrane.  Other synapses also see a voltage bump, with size and timing depending on their distance along the dendrite from the location of the arriving neurotransmitter burst, as well as the conduction qualities of the intervening membrane.[24]

If an exitory (depolarizing) action potential arrives at a second (nearby) synapse while it is already somewhat depolarized from the earlier exitory action potential at the first, the current caused by the burst will start at a lower (more depolarized) voltage and thus drag the voltage at that point lower than it would if the membrane was at normal resting potential.  If this lower voltage crosses the threshold for some concentration of a certain type of voltage-gated channels, they will open, creating a spike that wouldn't have happened in response to either action potential by itself.

In the dendrites, calcium spikes seem to be more common than sodium, although given its higher driving force channels that allow both through will probably show a bigger calcium effect than sodium.[4]  Calcium is useful in the dendrites, because the recovery from these spikes requires considerable energy and the elevated Ca+2 levels inside the cell stimulate the mitochondria to start producing more energy immediately, rather than waiting for the energy use to draw down the ATP/ADP ratio (as I've discussed previously).

The effects of all these various currents, as spread while decaying to the soma, axon hillock, and first part of the axon, determines whether and when an action potential will fire.  In order for that to happen, the voltage at the critical point (depending on the cell type) must fall below the threshold as a result of the combination of the effects of the various exitory (depolarizing) and inhibitory (hyperpolarizing) currents at various synapses.[24]  Large spikes in the dendrites can have a disproportionately large effect here, touching off action potentials when the combination of the original currents would never have caused this.[1]

Types of Spikes in Pyramidal Cell Dendrites

There are two major types of spikes that participate in dendritic calculation:  calcium spikes and NMDA spikes.[1]  Calcium spikes often propagate in a regenerative process similar to the action potential, at least in the apical dendrite (see Figure 1).[4]  They carry information generated in the apical tuft to the soma, where they can participate in the final decision whether/when to fire an action potential.  They are similar to sodium-driven action potentials, in that when a certain threshold depolarization is reached voltage-driven calcium channels open, causing a positive feedback.[4]  The typical recovery is mediated by calcium activated K+ channels which tend to be somewhat slower than those involved in the Na+-based action potential seen in the axon.  Once these channels open, the K+ current tends to repolarize and hyperpolarize the local membrane before they close, because unlike the voltage-gated K+ channels involved in the classic action potential they don't respond to changes in voltage, but stay open until the uptake of Ca2+ by the mitochondria is complete.[24]

NMDA spikes are different.[12]  NMDA receptors are for glutamate, the most common exitory neurotransmitter in the brain.  It is not the only one, the major fast response to glutamate from an action potential is mediated by AMPA receptors.  AMPA receptors are pretty much voltage independent:  they translate a certain sized burst of glutamate into a specific current of sodium and perhaps calcium (depending on the type).  NMDA receptors, OTOH, are both voltage sensitive and in need of some quantities of glycine, an otherwise inhibitory neurotransmitter released by other types of cells in the brain.  NMDA receptors are also subject to modulation by a wide variety of different substances, which can modify their response to glutamate as well as the threshold voltage for opening.

This threshold is caused by the tendency of extracellular Mg2+ to block the pore through which ions travel at higher (more polarized) voltages.  Thus a burst of glutamate can arrive at a synapse and cause only a small (or non-existent) current from AMPA receptors, while a much larger number of NMDA receptors stay silent, or perhaps only join in when the voltage is at its peak of depolarization.  However, if the synapse is already depolarized somewhat from other effects, including currents from action potentials at other synapses, nearby spikes (calcium and NMDA), and back-propagating action potentials form the soma, the arrival of the burst of glutamate could instead cause a much larger current:  an NMDA spike.[12]  (We should note that NMDA receptors are pretty non-specific regarding which positive ions they will pass:  Na+, K+, and Ca2+ will all have currents.)

These spikes tend to support very localized calculations.[1]  Inhibitory synapses, using either GABA or glycine, tend to produce Cl- currents, which in the dendrites are usually hyperpolarizing and also tend to resist the depolarizing effect of other exitory effects in their immediate vicinity.  These synapses, then, have a much greater effect in suppressing NMDA spikes in nearby exitory (depolarizing) synapses than their effect on the final voltage as felt at the soma.  The localized interactions tend to convert the fine dendritic branches of the basal dendrites into semi-independent calculating modules, and the implication of the paper being covered here is that the same is true of the fine dendritic branches of the apical tuft.  Thus, the exact same mechanism is used in both types of calculating module.[1]  We should also note that the ability of so many substances to modulate the threshold voltage of the NMDA receptor means that chemically mediated information is input directly into the most basic and fundamental system of dendritic calculation in the neocortex, as well as the rest of the "cerebral cortex, the hippocampus and the amygdala [...] primarily in structures that are associated with advanced cognitive functions".[4]  We should also note that these local calculations aren't limited to the dendrites of the cell ultimately firing the action potential:  the immediate chemical environment of both the NMDA receptors in the synapse and the various voltage-gated channels in the local membrane between them is subject to influences with sub-second timing from local membranes of many other nearby cells, both neurons and glia, as I've discussed before.

Contra the previous understanding, calcium spikes in the studied pyramidal neurons appear to be limited to the proximate apical dendrite (see Figures 1&2),[1] where "[s]everal properties, including the existence of local NMDA spikes and the weak electrogenesis of both sodium and calcium spikes, suggest that the relationship of the fine distal tuft branches to the apical Ca2+ initiation zone is similar to the relationship of the basal dendrites to the axosomatic initiation zone".[1] In Figure 2, then, we can see that the proximate apical dendrite serves as a "smart" relay, integrating the calculations made in the distal branches of the apical tuft and passing along the result to the soma (and axon hillock and early axon) where it is integrated with the results of calculations made (using the same or similar process) in the distal branches of the basal dendrites.

While there appear to be some minor differences between the apical and basal mechanisms, such as the "presence of hyperpolarization-activated current (Ih)" in apical dendrites,[1] these can probably be regarded as "fine-tuning" of the working of the integration process, perhaps to adapt it to the different functions of the apical and basal dendrites.  Overall, the similarity of function presented in this paper supports a much more unified paradigm for how calculations in pyramidal cells actually work.


Larkum, M., Nevian, T., Sandler, M., Polsky, A., & Schiller, J. (2009). Synaptic Integration in Tuft Dendrites of Layer 5 Pyramidal Neurons: A New Unifying Principle Science, 325 (5941), 756-760 DOI: 10.1126/science.1171958

Links:  I've included only the links called out in this leader.Only a few of the links here are called out in the text.  Far too many are behind paywalls; I've mentioned where links are formally open access.  Use the back key if you came by clicking a footnote. 

1.  Synaptic Integration in Tuft Dendrites of Layer 5 Pyramidal Neurons:  A New Unifying Principle paywall

2.  In vivo two-photon voltage-sensitive dye imaging reveals top-down control of cortical layers 1 and 2 during wakefulness

3.  Thalamic Input to Distal Apical Dendrites in Neocortical Layer 1 Is Massive and Highly Convergent paywall


4.  Pyramidal neurons:  dendritic structure and synaptic integration

5.  Properties of basal dendrites of layer 5 pyramidal neurons:  a direct patch-clamp recording study

6.  Calcium electrogenesis in distal apical dendrites of layer 5 pyramidal cells at a critical frequency of back-propagating action potentials Open Access

7.  Computational subunits in thin dendrites of pyramidal cells

8.  Ca2+ accumulations in dendrites of neocortical pyramidal neurons:  An apical band and evidence for two functional compartments paywall

9.  Signaling of Layer 1 and Whisker-Evoked Ca2+ and Na+ Action Potentials in Distal and Terminal Dendrites of Rat Neocortical Pyramidal Neurons In Vitro and In Vivo Open Access

10.  Apical tuft input efficacy in layer 5 pyramidal cells from rat visual cortex Open Access

11.  Role of dendritic synapse location in the control of action potential output

12.  The Properties and Implications of NMDA Spikes in Neocortical Pyramidal Cells Open Access

13.  Spatiotemporally Graded NMDA Spike/Plateau Potentials in Basal Dendrites of Neocortical Pyramidal Neurons Open Access

14.  Astrocytic control of synaptic NMDA receptors Open Access

15.  NMDA receptor-mediated dendritic spikes and coincident signal amplification paywall

16.  Diversity and Dynamics of Dendritic Signaling

17.  Dendritic arithmetic

18.  Polarized and compartment-dependent distribution of HCN1 in pyramidal cell dendrites

19.  Dendritic Computation

20.  Integrative Properties of Radial Oblique Dendrites in Hippocampal CA1 Pyramidal Neurons Open Access

21.  Dendrites:  bug or feature?

22.  Excitatory effect of GABAergic axo-axonic cells in cortical microcircuits requires free registration

23.  Cation–chloride co-transporters in neuronal communication, development and trauma paywall

24.  The synaptic organization of the brain Edited by Gordon M. Shepherd


Read more!

Monday, August 3, 2009

Scientia Pro Publica 9 is Up

Here.

Obviously, I'm not skipping a big post today:  after over two weeks without one, this morning's began to break the logjam.  Unfortunately, there's more to writing my posts than reading the appropriate papers and writing the post:  there's integrating and "making sense of" the mass of facts so they fit into a comprehensible framework.  The process tends to "clump", so there'll be dry periods, and weeks like the one that ended with Nature of the Neocortex, with four big posts. 

This is relevant because today's "Pro Publica" features my surprisingly successful Nature of the Neocortex, which I'm still trying to work out how/why (of the success).  It built on many previous posts, integrating ideas that would have been clumsy if I'd had to introduce them cold.  That may explain its popularity with regular readers, but not the number of new, outside links with recommendations.  I suppose my efforts to avoid jargon (and explain what I couldn't avoid) might be part of it, and I certainly hope my efforts to rationalize the details in both developmental and evolutionary terms contributed.

Back to Scientia Pro Publica 9, it's got a lot of good stuff in it, and I recommend giving it a good lookover. Read more!

Carnival of Evolution 14 is Up

(Actually last Saturday, but I missed it until now.)

Here. Read more!